Would you rather: Paxton $19 or Carrasco $25?

[SlideRule]

Another AL-only you-pick challenge.

Paxton $19
Carrasco $25

Both for next 2 years.

[Ken]

If I'm investing ~20-25 for 2 years I want the guy who has shown he can do it for 200 IP (and 176 IP average the last 3 years).

Paxton has never pitched 137 MLB innings in a season. Ever.

[Gregg]

If I'm investing ~20-25 for 2 years I want the guy who has shown he can do it for 200 IP (and 176 IP average the last 3 years).

Paxton has never pitched 137 MLB innings in a season. Ever.

Yep, I will pay the extra 6 bucks to get that.

[cavebird]

I like Paxton, but this one isn't close. Carrasco by a mile. If they go within $6 of each other in any draft I am in, I will be all over Carrasco.

[SlideRule]

Thanks all - got this one done. I get Carrasco $25 for Paxton $19, both keepable for 2018 and 2019.