mixed keepers - 12 team - help

[swampdragon]

standard yahoo 12 team league
runs, rbis, avg, sb, hrs
wins, era, whip, ks, saves

I can keep 4 players in their drafted rounds for one or two more years (if wanted)

Kdavis - round 16 - one more year - YES KEEP

JTurner - round 7 - could keep 2 years or one and wait to decide
ESuarez - round 28 - could keep 2 years or one and wait to decide
JGallo - round 15 - could keep 2 years or one and wait to decide
AVizcaino - round 26 - could keep 2 years or one and wait to decide
SGray - round 15 - could keep 2 years or one and wait to decide
EInciarte - round 18 - could keep 2 years or one and wait to decide
JBell - round 21 - could keep 2 years or one and wait to decide
OALbies - round 15 - could keep 2 years or one and wait to decide

any ideas from the pen

[chancellor]

I'd keep Turner, ESuarez, and Inciarte. I'd keep Inciarte for two years, the other two wait and decide. I'm not sure what will happen with Suarez once Senzel is up and playing, and given Turner's age, I'd be careful.

[Mithrandir]

In order of preference (one year)

Turner - gotta think he can keep up the solid play
Bell - I think he keeps improving. Just hope the shitty Pirates team doesn't inspire a malaise in him
Inciarte - since you have hits instead of rbi
Gallo - toss up with Suarez depending on your need for power.
Suarez - see Gallo

[swampdragon]

In order of preference (one year)

Turner - gotta think he can keep up the solid play
Bell - I think he keeps improving. Just hope the shitty Pirates team doesn't inspire a malaise in him
Inciarte - since you have hits instead of rbi
Gallo - toss up with Suarez depending on your need for power.
Suarez - see Gallo

thanks - actually it should be rbi not hits - my bad

[Mithrandir]

thanks - actually it should be rbi not hits - my bad

Then I might bump Gallo up with Inciarte, again depending on your preference.

[Sour Masher]

I'd keep Turner, Suarez, and Inciarte as well, but all for a year. Couldn't blame you for swapping Inciarte out for Gallo or Bell, based on needs and preferences. They are pretty close, and I think they could improve, whereas I expect Inciarte to regress simply because it is hard to repeat that PA total from last year.

[chancellor]

thanks - actually it should be rbi not hits - my bad

I'd still keep the same three, but the gap between Bell and Inciarte is much smaller.

[swampdragon]

anyone else? - 12 team - standard 5x5 (with average not OBA)

I am leaning this way - 4 to keep

Kdavis - round 16 - one more year - YES KEEP

JGallo - round 15 - KEEP
JTurner - round 7 - KEEP
EInciarte - round 18 - KEEP
ESuarez - round 26 - throw back - I guess
AVizcaino - round 26 - throw back - reluctantly
JBell - round 21 - throw back - reluctantly
OAlbies - round 15 -- throw back

[joncarlos]

I guess I don't think Ender is special in a 12-teamer. I'd rather take Albies.

I really like Suarez but I'm also not convinced he's special enough for a shallow league. Gallo could hit 50 bombs. Turner is right at value, but you need the AVG. So I'd go Gallo, Krush, Ozzie and Turner. But Turner vs. Suarez is a coin flip for that last spot.

[DMT]

I'd go Gallo, Krush, Ozzie and Turner.

Agreed