Puig for Rosario and Margot?

[Gregg]

NL only 5x5 $260 budget 12 team keeper.

Puig 20A for Rosario 5A and Margot 15A. All can be kept this year and next for these salaries.

All can be given a raise at $5 per year after this season.

Which side do you like better?

I am the Puig owner.

[DMT]

All three are risky at those prices so I'd rather have the side with the risk spread across two players.

[Hornsby]

I'd keep Puig...he's settled down, as noted elsewhere, and he still has growth potential. It's a reasonably fair deal, but I'd stick with the known quantity at this point.

Unless you need to fill keeper slots, then it's worth the risk to trade for the pair.

[Big Tymer]

Put me on the Rosario and Margot side but also comes down to your present last keeper since you add 2 players. Assuming you aren’t dropping anyone of value then I’d want the side with 2 quality players as well

[Gregg]

Put me on the Rosario and Margot side but also comes down to your present last keeper since you add 2 players. Assuming you aren’t dropping anyone of value then I’d want the side with 2 quality players as well

I have room for a 3 for 1 if needed.

[whalewang]

I prefer the Rosario/Margot side.

[fuhrdog]

I prefer the Rosario/Margot side.

Agreed, I wouldn't be shocked if Margot was as good as Puig in 2018.

[chancellor]

Put me on the Rosario and Margot side but also comes down to your present last keeper since you add 2 players. Assuming you aren’t dropping anyone of value then I’d want the side with 2 quality players as well

Same here. Especially since you've indicated you're likely in a rebuild year.

[Ken]

Agreed, I wouldn't be shocked if Margot was as good as Puig in 2018.

I would be

[BigJonEmpire]

I would be

I would too. Unless you are really excited about Margot's future I would hold Puig. I would want something more established for him.