Gio Gonzales or Luis Castillo

[Gregg]

Both are done this year Gonzales is $5 more than Castillo. Which would you prefer?

I do not own either.

[Sour Masher]

Give me Castillo and $5. Gio is so gonna regress this year. He will still be solid, I'd bet, but I'd take Castillo even if they cost the same.

[chancellor]

Give me Castillo and $5. Gio is so gonna regress this year. He will still be solid, I'd bet, but I'd take Castillo even if they cost the same.

Agree completely.

[harmon]

Castillo has ace written all over him.

[revo]

Agree with everything said.

[cavebird]

I would say it depends on situation. For value and easily for upside, Castillo is the obvious choice. If you have a great keeper list and need safety more than anything, go with Gio.