who do you trust more

[fuhrdog]

Kyle Gibson--2 road games Tigers and Indians

Doug Fister--3 games--At Bal, At Cin, and home vs Houston

2 week H2H finals--I need to drop one.

Dropping both isn't an option

[revo]

Ugh, Fister

[Mithrandir]

I dont think that there is anyone who could make that choice with confidence. No one
Complete crapshoot, hope to get lucky. I own both.

Flip a coin.

[DMT]

Fister has one more start and a higher K/9 so he's going to post more Ks. With so much uncertainty, I'd give the edge to Fister based on that alone.

[fuhrdog]

I dont think that there is anyone who could make that choice with confidence. No one
Complete crapshoot, hope to get lucky. I own both.

Flip a coin.

This is where I'm at. So 2 votes for Fister and 2 votes for who the f*** knows. Let's make this a best of 7 series. Who wants to chime in as game 5

[Sharky]

I agree it's a crapshoot. But personally I would go with Gibson. Seems to have turned a corner recently. And I think Fister has no upside. At least the Tigers are awful.

[Hornsby]

I'd go with Gibson...grudgingly. Last 4 games, only 4 earned runs...18 K's, only 2 walks.

[fuhrdog]

Crapshoot-2
Fister= 2
Gibson=2

Guess it's pretty close. Next vote is the winner....and the game 7 pick is?????

[Sharky]

Crapshoot-2
Fister= 2
Gibson=2

Guess it's pretty close. Next vote is the winner....and the game 7 pick is?????

Lol. After the 2-2 vote you said the fifth was a tiebreaker. Then you got two more Gibson votes. I'm sensing if you hear a 7th for Gibson you'll say ok, best 5 out of 9!

[fuhrdog]

Lol. After the 2-2 vote you said the fifth was a tiebreaker. Then you got two more Gibson votes. I'm sensing if you hear a 7th for Gibson you'll say ok, best 5 out of 9!

I said best of 7

[fuhrdog]

Lol. After the 2-2 vote you said the fifth was a tiebreaker.

Where did I say that? You been underwater for too long...come up for some air.

[DMT]

Gibson getting destroyed.

[Gregg]

Fister has one more start and a higher K/9 so he's going to post more Ks. With so much uncertainty, I'd give the edge to Fister based on that alone.

Yep.

This seems to be the best bad choice.

[Mithrandir]

Gibson getting destroyed.

Thats because hes a shitty pitcher who had a lucky stretch of 5 games or so.

[Mithrandir]

Gibson got the win!