AL trade evaluation

[SlideRule]

Which side do you like in a 10-tm AL keeper league?

Nelson Cruz $35A + Derek Norris $4A
or
Kluber $37A + Derek Fisher $5A

[Ken]

Which side do you like in a 10-tm AL keeper league?

Nelson Cruz $35A + Derek Norris $4A
or
Kluber $37A + Derek Fisher $5A

Kluber > Cruz, Fisher > Norris (especially keeper).

Not particularly close for me.

[SlideRule]

Yeah, based on the other "top tier SPs" thread we have going I think that's probably the common sentiment.

[revo]

Kluber > Cruz, Fisher > Norris (especially keeper).

Not particularly close for me.

Totally agree. And see the thread about the value of top tier SPs for more.

Only issue is I think Fisher will be traded, and that means there's a chance you lose him.

[Ken]

Only issue is I think Fisher will be traded, and that means there's a chance you lose him.

And even if you lose Fisher, the net loss was just Derek Norris in a 10 team league which isn't that big of a loss. He's on the bench in my 12 team AL Only...

[chancellor]

On pure value, Kluber/Fisher for me, too.

OTOH, if I can net 6-10 points in power categories versus pitching loss, I go get Nelson Cruz.