NL-ONLY trade help! Please!

12 team NL-ONLY (we keep 5). Should I take this deal?

I get - Anthony Rendon, DJ LeMeheiu
I trade - Cody Bellinger, Jesus Aguilar

My team

C - B Posey
C - T Murphy
1b - Belt
2b - Kendrick
SS - Peraza
3b - W Flores
1b/3b - T Joseph
2b/SS - Cosart
Of - Yelich
Of - Hamilton
Of - Osuna
Of - A Duvall
Util - Aguilar
Util - A Toles

Bench -C Bellinger



P - Bumgarner
p - cueto
P - m Moore
P - Foltinevich
P - Treinen
P - Kelley
P - AJ Ramos
p - Barraclaugh
P - A Garrett
P - Knebel


Should I take the deal?

[Hornsby]

I don't see any reason to, it really doesn't improve your team all that much. I like Flores more than most, and Kendrick isn't going to hit .330, but I don't think that LeMahieu is either. Bellinger is just too good to give up and not improve appreciably.

[The Dane]

So, Rendon+LeMahieu is better than Flores+Kendrick+Aguilar, but not really THAT much better. To be honest, I really like Flores' chances to get a lot of PT. I think Kendrick will be much better than people rated him going into this season. And Aguilar looks to have a nice little role with unexpected PT in MIL. These are three very good mid-to-late round targets. I get that the draft is over and now it's about crafting a roster that can win, but those are functional pieces for a league of this depth. At this point, Bellinger is, perhaps, the most exciting bat in the minors. I wouldn't give him up in this deal.

I actually like this team a lot. I'd wait a bit before you toss Bellinger to fix something that may not be broken.

[chancellor]

I'm going to say no, but for different reasons than Horns and The Dane. Looking at your roster, I don't think you can deal Bellinger without receiving a top flight SP back. Even in a deep league line this, that SP roster won't keep you competitive in Ws and Ks.

[Sharky]

I'm going to say no, but for different reasons than Horns and The Dane. Looking at your roster, I don't think you can deal Bellinger without receiving a top flight SP back. Even in a deep league line this, that SP roster won't keep you competitive in Ws and Ks.

I agree with chancellor on this one. If you get a really solid SP and a hitting upgrade, then maybe.

[Bgraham10]

I just essentially dealt Kendrick, Straily, Knebel and future picks for DeGrom, LeMehieu and Rendon. My team should be decent in depth

[pitbull]

I just essentially dealt Kendrick, Straily, Knebel and future picks for DeGrom, LeMehieu and Rendon. My team should be decent in depth

If that trade was in my league I have no doubt it would be protested. You literally stole candy from a baby.

[Sharky]

I just essentially dealt Kendrick, Straily, Knebel and future picks for DeGrom, LeMehieu and Rendon. My team should be decent in depth

Wow! Nice work.

[chancellor]

I just essentially dealt Kendrick, Straily, Knebel and future picks for DeGrom, LeMehieu and Rendon. My team should be decent in depth

I hope you bought him a beer or two.

[overkill94]

How did you pull that one off? It's not often you see one team get the 3 best players in a deal (by far) without getting some sort of stud keeper back.