Need quick feedback on a trade...

[chancellor]

AL Only, 5x5 with OBP and SLG replacing BA and HR, 11 teams -

I give Tulo at 15 for Castellanos at 11. No extensions available for either.

I have Andrus, Sano, JDyson as my other hitting keepers.

[Rush]

I would do it. Tulo is older and injury prone. Castellanos seemed to be turning the corner before his injury last year.

[Hornsby]

Yup, agree with Rush, do the deal.

[Sour Masher]

I guess it is the right move in an only league. I'm used to mix leagues, and I'd definitely stick with Tulo's upside/production when healthy in my 14 and 16 team leagues. But in those leagues, I have a viable bench options for when Tulo is hurt. In leagues that size, Tulo and his fill in when he is hurt would clearly outperform Castellanos, but that is probably not the case in an only league.

[cool hand]

I'm an AL only guy - I'd do that in a second.

[fuhrdog]

Seems like a pretty even trade to me so I'd probably take the $4 savings

[cool hand]

As a point of reference (and only a point of reference), in AL LABR Nick went 18, Tulo 16.