AL trade help -- keepers due this week

[Sharky]

12 team AL 5x5

I was offered Rougned Odor $13 (final year) for
Kelvin Herrera $10 (year 2), Marcus Stroman $7 (option), Andrelton Simmons $14 (who cares)

Would you do it? We can only keep 7. My keepers would be:

Mookie Betts $18 (2 yrs remaining)
JD Martinez $20 (final)
Tim Anderson $8 (year 2)
Rougned Odor $13 (final)
Edwin Diaz $11 (year 2)
Danny Salazar $5 (option; wouldn't extend)
Mark Trumbo $22 (year 2)

If I don't do the deal, I probably keep Herrera instead of Odor.

Thanks!!

[Rush]

I'd keep Herrera. He's a 4 category closer with his K's. You have a fair amount of offense on your keeper list already. But not knowing how your league values closers or the inflation rate, there may be something I'm not seeing.

[cool hand]

I'm in the Herrera camp as well in an AL only.
In my only, established closers command a salary premium.
Herrera has the look & feel of a top 7 closer to me.

[Sharky]

Thanks for the input. In our league pitchers (SP or closers) rarely get a good return in trades. I got both Herrera and Diaz via FAAB last year. Better chance to land a closer than a top hitter via FAAB. And I worry that Herrera could become a setup guy somewhere if KC tears it down this year. So I'm thinking I'll do it given our league dynamics. But your feedback makes it a tough call!!!

[chancellor]

In a non-OBP league, I'd take Odor. I really like Herrera, and am pretty confident he will stay in KC even during a tear down, but I'll take a power-speed 2B in a minute for a closer. You've already proven you can mine closers in waiting successfully.

[Vecmizer]

I love Odor but I would stay with Herrera as well. I am not a huge fan of giving away multiple years of control for 1 year unless it puts me over the top.