RJEL Keepers, Part Deux

[revo]

18 team, 5x5 w/OBP

I'm likely not a contender this season after surprisingly being one the last two seasons -- oh, and finishing just out of the money both times, yet having traded my 1st round pick which ended up being the #1 overall pick both years.

I need to pick my final two keepers:

DEFINITES
3B Bryant 6A
OF J. Bradley 8A
OF Duvall 1A
OF Grichuk 4A

SP deGrom 12 '18
SP Matz 6 Zero
SP R. Hill 2A
RP Familia 1B


POSSIBLES (Pick 2)
1B Trumbo 24A
1B Gurriel 18A
OF D. Peralta 3A
OF C. Gonzalez 32B
SP Pineda 17A
RP Kintzler 2A


I think I'm going with Kintzler and deciding between Trumbo and Peralta for the final spot. Who would you go with?

[Hornsby]

18 team, 5x5 w/OBP

I'm likely not a contender this season after surprisingly being one the last two seasons -- oh, and finishing just out of the money both times, yet having traded my 1st round pick which ended up being the #1 overall pick both years.

I need to pick my final two keepers:

DEFINITES
3B Bryant 6A
OF J. Bradley 8A
OF Duvall 1A
OF Grichuk 4A

SP deGrom 12 '18
SP Matz 6 Zero
SP R. Hill 2A
RP Familia 1B


POSSIBLES (Pick 2)
1B Trumbo 24A
1B Gurriel 18A
OF D. Peralta 3A
OF C. Gonzalez 32B
SP Pineda 17A
RP Kintzler 2A


I think I'm going with Kintzler and deciding between Trumbo and Peralta for the final spot. Who would you go with?

You can afford to have Trumbo...and Kinzler is fine, but I don't expect him to hold the job all year, but for 2 bucks, if you get 10 saves, you're well ahead of the game.

[DMT]

18 team, 5x5 w/OBP

I'm likely not a contender this season after surprisingly being one the last two seasons -- oh, and finishing just out of the money both times, yet having traded my 1st round pick which ended up being the #1 overall pick both years.

I need to pick my final two keepers:

DEFINITES
3B Bryant 6A
OF J. Bradley 8A
OF Duvall 1A
OF Grichuk 4A

SP deGrom 12 '18
SP Matz 6 Zero
SP R. Hill 2A
RP Familia 1B


POSSIBLES (Pick 2)
1B Trumbo 24A
1B Gurriel 18A
OF D. Peralta 3A
OF C. Gonzalez 32B
SP Pineda 17A
RP Kintzler 2A


I think I'm going with Kintzler and deciding between Trumbo and Peralta for the final spot. Who would you go with?

If you don't expect to compete, I'd keep Trumbo because he's a relatively cheap player who will be a good trading chip.

[Controller Jacobs]

I think Peralta will profit more, but Trumbo is probably the better keeper. Best to be insulated from HR scarcity.

[gcstomp]

Just for fun, what did the past 2 years # 1 picks end up being? Make yourself nuts, and imagine those 2 on your team. Carry on.

[revo]

Moncada & Senzel.