One injury removed

[heyelander]

Oh and for some reason they also have Chris Coghlan.

yeah, the guess is that either he or david nava, or some other guy who can give "professional at-bats" will be the 5th OF. Altherr is the only one that can play CF outside of herrera (unless Quinn makes the 25) so his job with the ML team is locked.

[Sharky]

That would be my best guess as well.

If you want one more Phillie who is in the same boat as a lot of these guys, it's ryse hoskins.

Almost for sure up this year: Crawford
Probably but needs something to happen: Quinn (trade, stay healthy), Williams (play well, injury), Alfaro (injury)
Long shot: Cozens (stays hot, injuries, everyone else fails), Hoskins (stays hot, Joseph collapses), Kingerly (Hernandez sucks or is traded)

Agreed on Hoskins, but I think it takes a complete implosion by Tommy Joseph for that to happen. Don't think they put Hoskins in the OF without giving him many more reps there in the minors.