Rank these AL players

[Sharky]

How would you rank these AL players (5x5)?

Victor Martinez $3
Ian Kinsler $25
Brad Miller $5
Mark Trumbo $21

All players entering option year. Thanks!

[joncarlos]

Miller - though I'm hesitant, the possibility of a .240 25/10 guy who is SS/1B/2B is too tough to pass up
VMart - would not argue at all if you put him #1. Though it would help if he could outrun me.
-----
Trumbo
Kinsler

[wombat104]

Miller
VMart
------
Trumbo


------
Kinsler (2nd base too deep to spend $25 on Ian)

[Rush]

Agree with Miller and VMart but if the Rays sign Lawrie. I'd worry about playing time a bit and would probably flop them

[joncarlos]

Agree with Miller and VMart but if the Rays sign Lawrie. I'd worry about playing time a bit and would probably flop them

He's still better than LoMo. I think Miller's ABs are relatively safe. His 2B eligibility, maybe not so much.

[Rush]

I agree he's better than LoMo but his counting stats are volume driven and even losing 75-100 total at bats might make VMart's numbers stronger

[joncarlos]

I agree he's better than LoMo but his counting stats are volume driven and even losing 75-100 total at bats might make VMart's numbers stronger

Looks like you're right. Last year he had 110 AB against lefties and hit .227-3hr-14rbi-8r-2sb

Would you prefer 438ab .247-27-67rbi-65r-6sb or .243-30-81-73r-8sb? I guess the hit to his AVG wasn't as bad as I thought it would be.

[Sharky]

Thanks guys! Am contemplating a trade for some of these guys. Very helpful.

[SlideRule]

Miller - though I'm hesitant, the possibility of a .240 25/10 guy who is SS/1B/2B is too tough to pass up
VMart - would not argue at all if you put him #1. Though it would help if he could outrun me.
-----
Trumbo
Kinsler

This is exactly what I was thinking, but didn't get a chance to reply until now.

[Sharky]

I have Salazar $5 and Stroman $7. How would you rank them in this mix (this year only)?

[virgonomic]

I'd slot them in

Miller
VMart
Salazar
------
Trumbo
Stroman
------
Kinsler

[joncarlos]

I have Salazar $5 and Stroman $7. How would you rank them in this mix (this year only)?

Miller 5 You gotta take the hitter right? I don't want to but I will
Salazar 5 I just can't quit him
----
VMart 3
----
Stroman 7 I think he's more innings eater-y than elite
Trumbo 21
----
Kinsler 25 I will agree with wombat that he's a step below