Final Keeper Help

So I'm in a 12 team h2h keeper league. 6x6 (standard 5x5 with .OPS), and I had Price as my 6th keeper. However, with the news on his elbow, and the fact we don't draft till Friday, I am able to make a switch. Right now my 5 keepers are:
Kershaw, Arenado, Odor, Springer, Yelich.

I have narrowed my 6th keeper to one of the three:
Posey, McCutchen, Pollock.

Thoughts?

Thanks.

[Sour Masher]

Is it a two catcher league? Eh, either way, I'd probably gamble on Pollock, although I do like McCutchen to bounce back in all ways but speed.

[Waltsanity]

It's a one catcher league. Position breakdown is
C. 1B. 2B. 3B. SS. OFx3, UTILx2, SPx2, RPx2, Px3 then bench.

[Sour Masher]

A league that shallow, I'm going to go for upside, and Pollock has the most of that.

[Waltsanity]

I forgot, I also don't have a 1st or 2nd round pick this year. I love Pollock too, his injury history concerns me though.

[Sour Masher]

I forgot, I also don't have a 1st or 2nd round pick this year. I love Pollock too, his injury history concerns me though.

Yes, I'd rank his risk as higher than McCutchen's, but replacement level is pretty high in your league, so I'd go for Pollock, who has the most upside.

[Ken]

Yes, I'd rank his risk as higher than McCutchen's, but replacement level is pretty high in your league, so I'd go for Pollock, who has the most upside.

Completely agree and you hit on the key point.

Small league means upside is much more important than floor since you can find floor level players easily on the wire.

Pollock.

[Waltsanity]

The hardest thing to do is cut ties with a player you drafted their rookie year. Cutch is that guy.