Roto Keepers

13 team 6x6 (OPS and QS) Roto League. 2 catchers. Which 4 of the following should I keep for this season only? Thanks!

Kyle Seager - Round 5
Masahiro Tanaka - Round 7
Justin Verlander - Round 10
Víctor Martínez - Round 15
Yasmani Grandal - Round 18
Aledmys Diaz - Round 25
Edwin Díaz - Round 25
Danny Duffy - Round 25
Blake Snell - Round 25
Drew Pomeranz - Round 25
Alex Cobb - Round 25
Trevor Story - Round 26

[madducks]

Story, Duffy, and both Diaz's.

[DMT]

Story, Duffy, and both Diaz's.

I'd probably keep Verlander instead of Aledmys but either is solid.

[chancellor]

Story, Duffy, and both Diaz's.

I agree with this.

[revo]

Story, Duffy, and both Diaz's.

Agreed.

[onejayhawk]

No question.

J

[Tomm0]

I was leaning towards Verlander over Aledmys myself although I don't think Verlander comes close to last season.

[joncarlos]

1. Story
2. Duffy (because QS)
3. Edwin (even though saves are only 1/6 categories)

I think I'd keep Aledmys over JV, but I really like JV and QS is a category, so I can see the argument. I'm assuming since you start 2 catchers, you have a MI slot as well, otherwise it's harder to keep Aledmys. Not only because you already have Story, but where does Aledmys really rank? [Correa, Seager, Villar, Lindor, Machado, Xander, Segura... that's 7 and then you're in a coin flip for guys like Swanson, Russell, Andrus, Asdrubal, etc]

[Gregg]

1. Story
2. Duffy (because QS)
3. Edwin (even though saves are only 1/6 categories)

I think I'd keep Aledmys over JV, but I really like JV and QS is a category, so I can see the argument. I'm assuming since you start 2 catchers, you have a MI slot as well, otherwise it's harder to keep Aledmys. Not only because you already have Story, but where does Aledmys really rank? [Correa, Seager, Villar, Lindor, Machado, Xander, Segura... that's 7 and then you're in a coin flip for guys like Swanson, Russell, Andrus, Asdrubal, etc]

Which is a good argument for me to keep JV along with Edwin, Duffy, and Story.