Announcement

Collapse
No announcement yet.

Announcement

Collapse
No announcement yet.

trade / keeper help

Collapse
X
 
  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

  • trade / keeper help

    The roster:
    C- Rupp $10
    1B- Hosmer $17/1
    2B- Rodriguez $10
    3B- Shaw $5
    SS- Bogaerts $30
    MI- Swanson $10
    CI- Rua $10
    OF- Benintendi $10
    OF- Harrison $9
    OF- Trout $25/4
    OF- Harper $25/4
    DH- Garcia $1
    P- Bradley $1
    P- Finnegan $10
    P- Herrera $1
    P- Strahm $10
    P- Moore $7
    P- JSmith $1
    P- Snell $10
    P- Straily $10
    P- Ziegler $7
    DL- Schwarber $13
    DL- Moustakas $19
    BN- Inciarte $1
    BN- Hedges $10
    BN- SGray $23
    BN- Harvey $10/2
    BN- Manaea $5
    BN- CReed $5
    Min- Albies $10
    Min- Fulmer $10
    Min- JHader $10
    Min- Newcombe $10

    6x6 - AVG, HR, R, RBI, K-BB, SB-CS and W, HD, SV, K, ERA, WHIP
    keep 6 ML and 4 MiL - ML salaries go up $3 first 3 years, $6 after
    prices are all last year, bolded my projected keepers - keeping Benintendi and Strahm as minors

    I've been offered:
    SP Quintana $12, C Realmuto $4, and 3B Senzel $10
    -FOR-
    OF Benintendi and either SS Bogaerts or SP Harvey

    Thoughts on my keepers? If I make the trade, who do you keep? And am I crazy for trying to trade Harper for his $22/2 Arrenado and $1 Torres?

  • #2
    Oh my don't you have the interesting collection of players.

    I like Realmuto, but with only 6 keepers and so many other choices he holds less value to me. Even less if it is a one catcher league.I pass on the first offer.

    Keeping Benintendi helps me make the decision to trade Harper for Arrenado an easier one.

    Comment


    • #3
      I think I agree with Gregg. Realmuto isn't a keeper, and I think I'd prefer Benintendi to Quintana straight up. I don't love the idea of keeping Harvey, so if this guy really wants Harvey, maybe explore a different deal. I also like the idea of trading Harper for Arenado.

      Comment


      • #4
        Agree with above, what does the bold represent in the list? Are those the players you are planning to keep?

        Comment


        • #5
          He'll only take Harper with Benintendi and Harper for Quintana/Realmuto/Arrenado/Senzel

          Comment


          • #6
            Originally posted by DJRadar View Post
            He'll only take Harper with Benintendi and Harper for Quintana/Realmuto/Arrenado/Senzel
            I do like Senzel, and it's not like Q is bad. Who is your 4th minor league keeper right now? And maybe you could flip Realmuto?

            Comment


            • #7
              Originally posted by DJRadar View Post
              He'll only take Harper with Benintendi and Harper for Quintana/Realmuto/Arrenado/Senzel
              No. Pass.

              Comment


              • #8
                Originally posted by DJRadar View Post
                He'll only take Harper with Benintendi and Harper for Quintana/Realmuto/Arrenado/Senzel
                How many teams? $260 budget?

                How does your league value pitchers? What are some of the top pitchers salaries? With only 6 keepers will any of the top pitchers be available?

                Comment


                • #9
                  $260 budget, 16 teams

                  Some of the top SP salaries:
                  Kershaw $51 - kept last year
                  Scherzer $47
                  King Felix $31
                  Price $29 - kept last year
                  Arrieta $24
                  Verlander $21
                  Sale $17

                  My 4th minor league keeper - if I keep 4 - would probably be Newcombe. Albies isn't going to be that productive, Fulmer is headed to the pen, so he's my only other option.

                  Comment


                  • #10
                    Originally posted by DJRadar View Post
                    He'll only take Harper with Benintendi and Harper for Quintana/Realmuto/Arrenado/Senzel
                    I have been thinking a lot about this. It is strong but I would pass. If he puts Torres back in instead of Senzel I would pull the trigger.

                    Comment


                    • #11
                      Hmm...gotta admit, I'd do the original deal. You get out of the potentially bad Harvey contract and upgrade at pitcher. That would give you six ML keepers of Hosmer, Bogaerts, Swanson, Trout, Harper, and Quintana. It's a net overpay for Q, but at least gets you one decent SP to go with five quality hitters.
                      I'm just here for the baseball.

                      Comment


                      • #12
                        He's made two offers -

                        1 - Quintana, Chapman $16, Realmuto, Torres $1, Senzel -FOR- Benintendi, Manaea, Harvey, Herrera

                        2 - Quintana, Realmuto, Torres, Senzel -FOR- Benintendi, Inciarte, Harvey, Manaea

                        I've tried getting his Arrenado $22/2, but he won't move him, even for Harper.

                        Thoughts on which offer I should take? Or if I should counter?

                        Comment


                        • #13
                          Originally posted by DJRadar View Post
                          He's made two offers -

                          1 - Quintana, Chapman $16, Realmuto, Torres $1, Senzel -FOR- Benintendi, Manaea, Harvey, Herrera

                          2 - Quintana, Realmuto, Torres, Senzel -FOR- Benintendi, Inciarte, Harvey, Manaea

                          I've tried getting his Arrenado $22/2, but he won't move him, even for Harper.

                          Thoughts on which offer I should take? Or if I should counter?
                          I am not taking either one of those offers.

                          I would offer Benintndi, Inciarte, and Harvey for Quintana Torres and Senzel.

                          Comment


                          • #14
                            I'm making a push for Altuve. The other owner wants Swanson +. How much more with Swanson should I offer?

                            Comment


                            • #15
                              How much does Altuve cost?
                              I'm just here for the baseball.

                              Comment

                              Working...
                              X