Mixed team minors

[chancellor]

I just inherited a mixed league team with this minors roster:

Aledmyis Diaz - OF
JP Crawford- SS
DJ Peterson 3B
Aaron Judge 1B
Austin Meadows - OF

We will need to cut down to four or three minors slits by the end of next week.

Who would you cut first and second?

TIA

[Hornsby]

Diaz is in the majors, if that helps.

I'd cut Peterson, and then Judge...

[joncarlos]

Peterson is an easy cut. Can you put JPC or Diaz on your major league roster and keep them for 5 bucks or something?

[chancellor]

I need to go back on Diaz. He's listed as an OF, so someone either has him at the wrong position or I have the wrong Diaz.

[Ken]

Diaz is in the majors, if that helps.

I'd cut Peterson, and then Judge...

I agree on Peterson first. Why judge rather than Meadows as the 2nd cut.

[Hornsby]

I agree on Peterson first. Why judge rather than Meadows as the 2nd cut.

I think that Meadows has a far greater skill set, but not the opportunity at this time. I think that there's a whole lot of swing and miss in Judge's game that will really be exploited in the bigs.

[Captain Hook]

agree on Peterson, but in addition I don't have much confidence that Crawford is worth a spot when there are so many better players available

[Big Tymer]

I think that Meadows has a far greater skill set, but not the opportunity at this time. I think that there's a whole lot of swing and miss in Judge's game that will really be exploited in the bigs.

Agree 100% - no reason to write the same thing. Every now and then, Steve is a smart man

[kawaise]

I think that Meadows has a far greater skill set, but not the opportunity at this time. I think that there's a whole lot of swing and miss in Judge's game that will really be exploited in the bigs.

Another in agreement with dropping Judge over Meadows.

I saw Peterson play last year in AAA - he did nothing to make me think that he's going to be a MLB regular.