Keeper Question|Advice

[benjamincarm]

10 Team H2H 5x5 league: We can keep 15 players under 30 and 4 players over 30. I have identified most of the guys I want to keep, but looking for some advice/crowd-sourcing on the rest. There is not any salaries or limits involved.

Right now I think I have my 4 over guys set, although I'd like to make room for Evan if I could. Below is my current roster with over/under for the age and (k) if I plan on keeping right now. Any thoughts/advice on who my last 2 under keepers should be?


Hitters
Nolan Arenado – Under (k)
Xander Bogaerts – Under (k)
Alex Bregman – Under (k)
Byron Buxton – Under (k)
Yoenis Cespedes – Over (k)
Khris Davis – Under (k)
Billy Hamilton – Under (k)
Jonathan Lucroy – Over (k)
Rougned Odor – Under (k)
Gregory Polanco – Under (k)
Brendon Rodgers – Under (k)

Michael Conforto – Under
Evan Longoria – Over
Tom Murhpy – Under
Anthony Rendon – Under
Devon Travis – Under
Mark Trumbo – Over
Troy Tulowitzki – Over
Jesse Winker – Under

Pitchers
Carlos Carrasco – Over (k)
Kenly Jansen – Under (k)
Corey Kluber – Over (k)
Sean Manea – Under (k)
Alex Reyes – Under (k)
Blake Snell – Under (k)

Anthony DeSclafni – Under
Brandon Finnegan – Under
Seth Lugo – Under
Jose Quintana – Under
Carlos Rodon – Under
Taijuan Walker – Under

[joncarlos]

I need to think about this a bit more, but with Arenado already on board, is Longoria really a keeper worth worrying about in a 10-team league? My gut says no. I'd like to have a top catcher, so Lucroy stays, and I definitely keep the 2 Indians. So that leaves Yo or Longoria, and I think I trust Yo more.

I probably add Quintana as one under. I'd like the stability with all those young/risky arms. Really not sure about the last one. My gut says Rendon.

[benjamincarm]

I have Quintana, Rodon, and Rendon in mind as likely to be "favorites". I am not crazy about the move, but I keep waiting and expecting Walker to do something.

I picked up Lugo, Walker, Finnegan, and Conforto on the last day of waivers at the end of the season so I don't have any time invested in them, but their upside was intriguing.

Thanks for the thought joncarlos.