Rank theses closers for 2017

[canadianboy]

Davis
Kimbrel
Giles
Herrera
Oh
Diaz

[madducks]

Davis
Kimbrel
Oh
Diaz
Herrera
Giles

I need to see Diaz and Herrera close for a full season before i become a true believer. Oh has closing experience in Japan. And Giles has to re-earn my trust after last year. I would be willing to take a gamble on the last three late in the draft or if the price was low at auction.

OK, maybe i would go higher if i was really desperate for a closer.

[canadianboy]

Do you worry at all about Davis`s late-season elbow issues which cost him the entire month of August ? I was thinking Kimbrel, Oh, Davis, Diaz, Giles, Herrera. I totally agree about Giles and wanting to see Diaz and Herrera for a year.

[madducks]

Do you worry at all about Davis`s late-season elbow issues which cost him the entire month of August ? I was thinking Kimbrel, Oh, Davis, Diaz, Giles, Herrera. I totally agree about Giles and wanting to see Diaz and Herrera for a year.

No, i'm sure the Cubs did an extensive medical check on Davis before trading for him. And i don't think he had any further issues in September.

[chancellor]

Do you worry at all about Davis`s late-season elbow issues which cost him the entire month of August ? I was thinking Kimbrel, Oh, Davis, Diaz, Giles, Herrera. I totally agree about Giles and wanting to see Diaz and Herrera for a year.

Yes. Yes. Yes.

I like Giles better than Diaz, other than that like your list.

[Moonlight J]

Giles is the best closer on that list

bold prediction: highest R$ earner in 2017 for closers

[joncarlos]

If you had asked "how would you rank these closers?" I would have said "with a dartboard."

Davis is probably fine, but why risk it in this group?

Giles
Diaz
---
Kimbrel
Oh
---
Davis
Herrera

[revo]

Kimbrel
Davis
Giles
Herrera
Oh
Diaz