trading for keepers

[swampdragon]

12 team - yahoo league - standard cats

we can keep 4 in the round they were drafted for 2 years - only 4

These are my keepers
pollock - round 9 - last year
bogaarts - round 11 - last year
desmond - round 7 - 2 years
piscotty - round 12 - 2 years

probably not making cut
mccullers - round 10 - 2 years
kdavis - round 13 - 2 years
valencia - round 15 - 2 years
gallo - round 25 - 2 years
cobb - round 26 - 2 years

a team has offered me
odor - round 13 - last year
hendricks - round 18 - 2 years

for bogaarts and piscotty

thoughts on keepers and trade

[revo]

No thanks. Pass.

[mjl]

I don't hate it. Don't love it either. I think it's fair, do it if you have a personal preference for some of the players.

I think Piscotty is pretty replaceable in a 12-mixed - he's clearly good but he's not that much better than KDavis or Valencia (tbh I'd probably keep Valencia assuming he ends up with a starting job somewhere). Hendricks is probably a better last keeper than those guys if you have any faith in his performance, but it's a pretty big sample size now. Bogaerts is better than Odor but maybe not by a ton.

[virgonomic]

I'd stick with the guys you have.

[Hornsby]

Yup...no deal.

[mjb887]

Would rather have your guys and the round differences don't make up the gap. Pass.

[swampdragon]

thanks - that is what I thought

I will wait and see if
valencia
davis
piscotty becomes my fourth keeper