Urias or Neil Walker?

[Gregg]

NL only 5x5 keeper. $260 Budget.

Walker is $22 for the next two years can extend after next year $5 per year. Urias is free next year as long as he doesn't get too many innings (probably won't). He then becomes $15 for the next 3 years but can also be extended at $5 per year after year two.

Who would you rather have moving forward?

[revo]

Urias and it's not close.

[madducks]

Urias.

[chancellor]

Urias for sure. His slow start looks like it gave you a kick of a buying opportunity.

Even if Walker is a significant bite on your hitting, I'd be shocked if you can't turn around in a month and get a much better return from a dumping team for Urias

[overkill94]

Urias although you'll have to be patient. Although he'll probably spend most (if not all) of next year in the rotation, they'll still be limiting his innings a little bit - probably around 160 IP. Won't be until 2018 that we see him unleashed which will hopefully coincide with him working out all the kinks.

[revo]

FYI Walker is a free agent after the season, so there's a 50/50 chance he heads to the AL.