RP for SP trade

[Sam]

I have a strong RP collection but need some help with my starting pitching. I'm looking to do a 1 for 1 deal with another owner and wanted to get some opinions on how to value the trade. Still aiming for this year, not in re-build mode.

My RP:
Hector Rondon - $10 - one more year left on his contract
Cody Allen - $9 - two years left
AJ Ramos - $9 - two years left
Arodys Vizcaino - $4 - two years left
Boxberger - $3 - two years left

His trade-able SP:
Cueto - non-keeper
Gerrit Cole - non-keeper
Taijuan Walker - $8 - two years left
Odorizzi - $8 - two years left
McCullers - $3 - two years left

Which closer would you look to trade away? Which SP would you look to acquire? What would give me the best bang for my buck in a 1-for-1 deal?

[virgonomic]

I'd give Rondon or Vizcaino for Cueto.

I'd want Walker for any of the guys on longer contracts.

[revo]

Allen's been the shakiest, but might fetch the least, if anything at all. Boxberger is next, because Colome's been lights out.

McCullers has been the hardest hit of these pitchers, so maybe try for him for one of the above two? If not, then Odorizzi?

If he balks at the two RP mentioned, hell, trade any-- do you need five closers, lol?

[Hornsby]

I'd target Cole, and hit him with Vizcaino...appeal to the cheap keeper nature with great skills. If that didn't work, Allen for McCullers...I'd shoot for Cueto, but you probably will have to sweeten the pot.

[Sam]

Thanks all! With Boxberger getting hurt again tonight I'm going to hang tight. Other owner would've done Allen for McCullers or Rondon for Odorizzi so there's at least some talking points for the future.

[Sour Masher]

I'd be shocked if the Cueto owner took any of your guys 1 for 1, but that is who'd I'd want to get. Of course, you'd be buying high there, so it might be smarter to trade to get Cole or Walker in that order.