Vasquez/Castro/Barnhart/Casali/Hermann - Which One Do You Want?

[Batteredballs]

I am sitting with D'Arnaud and Vasquez as my 2 starting Catchers. I don't really have a good option for D'Arnaud and am prepared to carry him on my active roster for a while. That leaves me with what to do about Vasquez. Should I drop him to pick up one of these guys? 1. Casali 2. Castro 3. Herrman 4. Barnhart. Herrman in on fire, but I worry about AB's....Having said that he is only getting about4 AB/wk less than the other guys?? Barnhart doesn't seem to offer much more than Vasquez at this point. Castro and Casali seem to blow hot and cold?? Thoughts/suggestions?? Thanks.

[chancellor]

I'd keep Vasquez.

[Ken]

Anyone have a 5 sided dice with a picture of a pile of shit on each side?

[overkill94]

Might as well stick with Vasquez, at least he's in a great lineup. Herrmann is fool's gold - nothing in his track record indicates he'll maintain even close to this level of production. Plus, now that Tomas is over his neck thing there will be a lot fewer at-bats in the outfield and even less if Peralta avoids the DL.