Thoughts on a deal . . .

[kldub4life]

I made 2 trades in one dynasty league yesterday (6x6 h2h obp and holds)

Which side do you like most:

Team A:
K. Seager
T. Tulowitzki
P. Fielder
F. Hernandez

Team B
A.J. Pollock
E. Hosmer
M. Duffy
S. Cisheck

[Ken]

I made 2 trades in one dynasty league yesterday (6x6 h2h obp and holds)

Which side do you like most:

Team A:
K. Seager
T. Tulowitzki
P. Fielder
F. Hernandez

Team B
A.J. Pollock
E. Hosmer
M. Duffy
S. Cisheck

Personally I'd take A and it's not particularly close.

[heyelander]

Without money or contracts I think A is much better.

[joncarlos]

Team A gets 4 veterans who look awful. Which is a really interesting thing to get in a dynasty league. Big fan of Hosmer and Pollock but Cishek and Duffy are very blah. I'll take side A.

[Sour Masher]

Yeah, even in a dynasty, I go with side A.

[kldub4life]

I am Team A

Both moves are all in moves to win this year.

The first trade was Seager/Tulo for Pollock/Duffy

I was starting B. Miller and Duffy

Giving up Pollock was hard to say the least, but the shoulder injury could be something that lingers even into next season.

The 2nd deal was Fielder/Hernandez for Hosmer/Cisheck

Giving up Hos hurts long-term, but short-term I feel Prince is about equal. I just put Carrasco on the DL so getting Felix was a coup in my thought especially when considering Cisheck was my 6th closer lol.

[Sour Masher]

You did well. Pollock might hurt long term, but as you say, who knows how that shoulder issue lingers? Hosmer is a solid player, but he isn't irreplacable. His lack of power at 1b makes him the sort of long term player I always try to move in such deals--he has long term value, but isn't a true stud.

[Batteredballs]

Side A for me as well. Not really high on Duffy or Cichek. Pollack makes it close but I would still go A.