So what is Trevor Story's real value?

[james33]

Ignoring keeper value, which is quite different across leagues with different rules and salaries, how do you rank Trevor Story for the rest of the year among NL shortstops? 15 are listed below for your convenience.

Corey Seager
Addison Russell
Jung-Ho Kang
Brandon Crawford
Jean Segura
Eugenio Saurez
Jonathan Villar
Erick Aybar
Alexei Ramirez
Asdrubel Cabrera
Jose Reyes
Zach Cozart
Jedd Gyorko
Jhonny Peralta
Nick Ahmed

[joncarlos]

NL SS is kind of a wasteland. I think he's probably #3. I'd probably put him around .240-18-10sb from today forward.

Seager should hit .280 with similar power #s but no speed.
---
Russell is actually really similar, hits lower in the order and doesn't have Coors on his side. Depends on your preference
Story
Segura depends a lot on whether you believe and what you need, isn't similar at all, but could be .265 with 30 steals and 8-9 HR
---
Suarez is also pretty similar in all honesty.. .250ish with low double digit SBs and high double digit power
Crawford is probably .250 and 18 HR but no speed
Kang is like Crawford with more AVG and less knee ligaments

After that, probably Asdrubal, Villar, Aybar, Peralta

[james33]

Intersteing, I'm much more bearish. Went with #7-#8. Villar & Aybar SB+HR (not a real category, but I sometimes use SB+HR as a quick&dirty calculation) seem similar to Story's going forward, while Suarez/Crawford/Kang seem more secure in their jobs.

[pitbull]

I have to agree with JC. Playing at Coors and batting 2nd gives Story an extra boost. NL SS not a great group.

[onejayhawk]

I'm going with 5th, but that's just to be safe. I can't pick four guys ahead of him.

J

[Gregg]

I would take Segura, Seager, and Kang before Storey.

[ThatRogue]

Perhaps Brandon Crawford too...