RJEL keepers (mostly pitching questions)

[mjl]

18-team 5x5 using OBP. What few studs are in the auction will go in the high 40s/low 50s. 10 keepers plus a ton of minor leaguers.

Definites:
CDavis $17
Dozier $8
Trout $25
Calhoun $12
Forsythe $1

Considerations:
Valencia $5
Doolittle $1
Eickhoff $4
Fiers $3
Hammel $7
McGee $4
Tanaka $22
Vizcaino $5

if you think I should keep Doolittle, Fiers, or McGee, should I give them an extra year at $5 extra? My guess is no but I'm not sure.

Also note that I have a ton of minor leaguers who are likely to contribute this year, for what that's worth - I like my prospects to be close to the majors. So I have the following who don't count as keepers in the above but will probably be relevant/maybe ought to inform my decisions:

AJ Reed
JP Crawford
Jabari Blash
Max Kepler
Mallex Smith
Tyler White
Colin Walsh
Mark Appel
Jorge Lopez
Mychal Givens

[Controller Jacobs]

I think I'd go
McGee $4
Fiers $3
Hammel $7
Valencia $5
...with no extensions. Valencia (3b/of)/Forsythe(2b/1b) are a nifty eligibility combo.

[joncarlos]

McGee, Doolittle, Hammel.. and maybe Valencia, but I question if he would go for more.

[Gregg]

McGee, Doolittle, Hammel.. and maybe Valencia, but I question if he would go for more.

I would keep these. I would give Doolittle a 1 year raise.

[chancellor]

McGee, Fiers, Dolittle, and Valencia. I'd take the chance on Hammel that I could get him back for 7 or less - his numbers last year certainly weren't really good. No extension on any of them.

[bryanbutler]

i'd keep both mcgee and doolittle but wouldn't extend either. also like fiers at $3.

[The Dane]

i'd keep both mcgee and doolittle but wouldn't extend either. also like fiers at $3.

Agreed.

[madducks]

Valencia $5
Doolittle $1
Eickhoff $4
Fiers $3
McGee $4

No extensions.