Looking for some Keeper help please

I am in a 12 team, H2H, Standard 5x5 scoring (with .OPS and K/BB, so it's a 6x6). We are able to keep 6 players.

I have somewhat of an idea of who I want to keep, however I'm getting a lot of back and forth opinions on who my sixth keeper should be. I would like your opinions on who your six would be please.

Positional Breakdown: C, 1b, 2b, 3b, SS, OF x3, Util x2, SP x2, RP x2, P x3, then bench spots.

The options:
Clayton Kershaw
David Price
Corey Kluber
Andrew McCutchen
AJ Pollock
George Springer
Justin Upton
Nolan Arenado
Dee Gordon
Prince Fielder

Those are more or less the obvious options. I'll toss a few more in the mix.
Marcus Stroman
Steven Matz
Masahiro Tanaka
Aroldis Chapman
Kenley Jansen
Corey Seager

My original thinking is to keep: Kershaw, Price, McCutchen, Springer, Pollock, Arenado

Any help/opinions are very much appreciated.

Thank you.

[Pogues]

If it was my team, I'd keep Kershaw, Kluber, Cutch, Pollock, Arenado, and Gordon. Your problem is too many good choices!

[Gregg]

If it was my team, I'd keep Kershaw, Kluber, Springer, Pollock, Arenado, and Gordon.

I like Springer better that Cutch or Pollock this year. And I like Pollock better than Cutch. I am concerned about McCutchen's sb's.

[mjl]

No way you keep Gordon. Note that OPS is added as a sixth category. Unless you're pretty sure Gordon is going to hit over .300 again - which he certainly could, but would be necessary to keep his OPS close to league average - Gordon is way above average in one category (SB), above average in two (AVG, R), average to below in one (OPS), and way below in two (HR, RBI). And it's a H2H league, and with Cutch and Pollock and Springer you already have guys who are going to steal some bases. You don't get a carryover bonus for crushing someone by 5 or 10 SB in a week.

I'd keep the list you proposed.

[Gregg]

No way you keep Gordon. Note that OPS is added as a sixth category. Unless you're pretty sure Gordon is going to hit over .300 again - which he certainly could, but would be necessary to keep his OPS close to league average - Gordon is way above average in one category (SB), above average in two (AVG, R), average to below in one (OPS), and way below in two (HR, RBI). And it's a H2H league, and with Cutch and Pollock and Springer you already have guys who are going to steal some bases. You don't get a carryover bonus for crushing someone by 5 or 10 SB in a week.

I'd keep the list you proposed.

I actually do think he will hit over .300 this year. 27 years old prime of his baseball life.

[Waltsanity]

Thank you for the replies and opinions. I appreciate everyone's insight.

[Sour Masher]

I'm with Eld in that you really can't go wrong keeping and of your top 8-9. I've admitted elsewhere that I tend to devalue no pop speedsters, so I am in the camp that would probably keep not keep Gordon, given the extra category of OPS. My top 6 would be Kershaw, Kluber, McCutchen, Springer, Pollock, Arenado.

So, your original list, but I like Kluber a tad more than Price. I think they are both about that same level of awesome in most cats, but I like Kluber for more Ks, and also have a bit better k/bb ratio. Your extra cat puts Kluber in the lead by a hair imo (although he will probably lose out in era and wins to Price).