For 2016, who would you rather have

[luckyheel]

NL only 9 team 5x5 league

My current potential keepers are: Bryant-10, Duda-11, Blackmon-16, Dickerson-14, MTaylor-10, Marte-25, Kang-7, JHarrison-16, Reyes-11, Polanco-15, Schwarber-10

I have one contending owner interested in Marte... Would you deal him for any of the following??


BHamilton-15 and SMatz-7
or
Hamilton and JTurner-6
or
Turner and Matz


T.I.A.

[Hornsby]

Yeah, I'd probably do that deal for Hamilton and Turner...as much as Matz may be good, we simply haven't seen enough of him at this point. Or see what else you can get for Marte, it's not like Hamilton is without warts, and Marte could steal 30-40 bags in a good year. So there's no reason to deal him for anything but top dollar.

[chancellor]

I'd take Hamilton and Turner in that deal in a minute. I'm admittedly more positive on Turner than most others.

[Sharky]

Hamilton and Turner because of Hamilton's skill set.

[revo]

I'd stick with Marte.

I'm not 100% convinced that Turner stays as an everyday regular next season, and Hamilton could see himself back in the minors. Matz could be a star, and I think he will be, but Marte in an NL-only has to be one of the best all-around fantasy bats there are.