Please help me evaluate trade.

[FBP]

NL only keeper league. Still,on fringes of contention but an eye on 2016. I get $1 Hernan Perez for $10 Asche?

[Sharky]

Asche seems to have a better window for playing time. Perez will get first crack at the 3B job in MIL now that Aramis is gone. I have to think that neither has much value for 2016 frankly. And for this year I think Asche might be the safer bet. But if you're rolling the dice, a $1 Hernan Perez seems like more of the lottery ticket play. A lot easier to exceed $1 in value than $10.

[Judge Jude]

HPerez might be... respectable, and better than Asche in both years.
#babysteps

[overkill94]

Woof, I'd drop both of them (and someone did just drop Asche in my 12-team NL-only) - Perez has horrible numbers in both his minor and major league careers, I wouldn't get too excited about <100 at-bats on the Brewers.

[chancellor]

I'd take a flyer on a $1 Perez, but I agree with overkill that neither will likely have much value

[FBP]

How about a $5 Gyorko?

[overkill94]

How about a $5 Gyorko?

Eh, he's got more upside than those two although it'll be interesting to see how the playing time works when Spangenberg comes back

[onejayhawk]

Eh, he's got more upside than those two although it'll be interesting to see how the playing time works when Spangenberg comes back

Gyorko is a career sub .300 OBA. Even in SD that will not float.

J

[chancellor]

How about a $5 Gyorko?

Marginally better, though only a bit.