steve vogt ?

[wannabegriffey]

How does the pen feel about steve vogt as a $5 keeper for next year in an a.l. only, 12 team league ??

[chancellor]

How does the pen feel about steve vogt as a $5 keeper for next year in an a.l. only, 12 team league ??

Really good. He's going to cool off from his ridiculous numbers he's put up the first two months, but I'd have a hard time figuring out how you could do better for five bucks at C in a deep league

[Lucky]

Yeah, he did cool down for a couple of weeks, as I was expecting, then came back and hit a cool .330 the next two, which I was not expecting.

I have him at $8, and can't decide to sell high or hold on.

[overkill94]

My dad used to coach him in all-stars when he was 12 so he's super awesome

Even if it's a 1 catcher league he seems like a great keeper, at least for a couple years.

[Erik]

Yeah, he did cool down for a couple of weeks, as I was expecting, then came back and hit a cool .330 the next two, which I was not expecting.

I have him at $8, and can't decide to sell high or hold on.

In a vacuum, I'd say hold. However, if you're playing for this year and are deficient in certain categories, and he's your best chip, then it wouldn't hurt to see what he might fetch.

[luckyheel]

Wanted to bump this one up...in a vaccum, would you deal $5 Vogt in a deal to get $5 Correa

[swampdragon]

Wanted to bump this one up...in a vaccum, would you deal $5 Vogt in a deal to get $5 Correa

yep - SS is so shallow and the ceiling is high for Correa - but I doubt the Correa owner would do it right now

[luckyheel]

He's contending and I offered him Gattis-28, Vogt-5, CDavis-19 and Semien-10 for Correa-5 and JDMartinez-11...we'll see. His catchers are Gomes and Perez, so the batting averages of Davis and Gattis are actually better (which is a category he is concerned about). I'm not sure I would do the deal if I were him, as Correa is a steal for the next several years...but, he is getting a significant upgrade in hitting categories for rest of season without losing much

[swampdragon]

He's contending and I offered him Gattis-28, Vogt-5, CDavis-19 and Semien-10 for Correa-5 and JDMartinez-11...we'll see. His catchers are Gomes and Perez, so the batting averages of Davis and Gattis are actually better (which is a category he is concerned about). I'm not sure I would do the deal if I were him, as Correa is a steal for the next several years...but, he is getting a significant upgrade in hitting categories for rest of season without losing much

please post this a new thread - not just ask would you trade correa for vogt - that first question has nothing to with the second question

[luckyheel]

understoop, swamp...I usually don't piggy back on other threads...