heyward or dom brown or mccutcheon-5?

[james33]

Dumping this year in 12-team 5x5 NL-only. Giving up some top players in last year of contract/high salaries for my choice of any 2 of the following:

McCutcheon $16 through 2013
Heyward $11 through 2013
Dom.Brown $11 through 2013

Inflation typically 40% in this league.

Which two?

[Hammer]

Easil cutch and heyward

[Sam]

Easil cutch and heyward

Agree with Hammer on this one

[joncarlos]

Yeah I don't see how this is a choice. In theory Brown has more value down the road than Heyward because he can run more. But who knows how well his hamate will really heal? Will he be 100% next year?

[Gregg]

Pull that trigger on McCutcheon and Heyward now. Don't want anybody uping your offer.

[james33]

thanks, all - I have some irrational exhuberance for Dom. Brown so thanks for bringing me back to earth. I probably shouldn't even have mentioned Heyward as I felt he was clearly the best one but couldn't decide between Brown and McCutchen.

by the way, what's a hamate?

[Hammer]

I believe its a bone in your hand.

[Sharky]

I believe its a bone in your hand.

Isn't that worth two in the bush?