PONY Keepers 2015

[frae]

Here is what I am leaning toward and then what I have on the outside looking in...


Guaranteed Contracts

Buster Posey 15
Kyle Seager 10
Madison Bumgarner 15

Locks to Keep

Mark Melancon 1 opt (extend 1 year to $6?)
Charlie Blackmon 1
Joaquin Benoit 1

The Bubble, but in

Jacoby Ellsbury 29 opt
Adrian Gonzalez 30
David Price 27
Starlin Castro 18

The bubble, but out

Scooter Gennett 5
Henderson Alvarez 3
Brad Miller 5
Jose Reyes 29
Kris Medlen 1

I can see the argument for Miller and Gennett over 2 of the at value studs, but I am hesitant. I like the A-Gon Ellsbury combo for under 60 and Price and Bumgarner give me a nice 1-2 punch for under 50. What do you guys think? Thanks!

[Vecmizer]

I like your list. I think keeping the definite stats is worth the price and you go into the auction with a nice start to power and speed and SP and Saves. You wont be held hostage by having to go hard after one category that you your keepers didn't address.

[joncarlos]

yeah, I wouldn't change anything. I'm not a huge Miller guy.

I mean, wait... keep Kris Medlen!

[axman]

I'd go with your list but keep Gennett over Castro. Tough call on extending Melancon. Not sure I would but I'm very adverse to extending pitching.

[seahawxx]

Are there any openings for 2015? Former champion Beagle Pit misses you guys!