Trading Matt Kemp?

[Falcon]

Have a trade offer on the table in my 10-team, NL-only, 5x5, 10-keeper, straight-draft (no $$) league that involves dealing Matt Kemp for Nolan Arenado and Aramis Ramirez. With Stanton, Kemp, Holiday, Heyward and Revere in my OF, I'm looking to deal one for a CI or two.

Here are my keepers:

Stanton
Kemp
Holiday
Heyward
Revere
Hamels
Arrieta
deGrom
Rosenthal
Kimbrel

Bubble guys:
Cashner
Roark
Syndergaard

Thoughts on this deal?

[mjl]

Are you planning to keep both of them? Who would you remove from your keeper list for that? Given how good everyone on your list already is, I'd probably be trying to include whoever you wouldn't be keeping and get a better second player back.

That said, I'd definitely do it - I would probably do Kemp for Arenado by himself but I haven't though about it enough to be sure.

[joncarlos]

I don't think I like Aramis better than Rosey, but there's a compelling argument to trade Kemp for Arenado straight up anyway. (And get Aramis for free if you can, maybe you can flip him). I would try to throw in Rosey and get someone better (or Cashner, who I might keep over Rosey anyway)

[Gregg]

Have a trade offer on the table in my 10-team, NL-only, 5x5, 10-keeper, straight-draft (no $$) league that involves dealing Matt Kemp for Nolan Arenado and Aramis Ramirez. With Stanton, Kemp, Holiday, Heyward and Revere in my OF, I'm looking to deal one for a CI or two.

Here are my keepers:

Stanton
Kemp
Holiday
Heyward
Revere
Hamels
Arrieta
deGrom
Rosenthal
Kimbrel

Bubble guys:
Cashner
Roark
Syndergaard

Thoughts on this deal?

If you can get both of those guys straight up for Kemp you have to do it. Then take Ramirez and deGrom and upgrade at pitching or get a very good SS.

[Falcon]

What if I asked for Lucroy rather than A. Ram? Thoughts?

[joncarlos]

What if I asked for Lucroy rather than A. Ram? Thoughts?

I like that more. Even in a 1 catcher league.

[Sharky]

What if I asked for Lucroy rather than A. Ram? Thoughts?

That would be awesome if you can make it happen.

[the heat]

I like that more. Even in a 1 catcher league.

Me too +1

[Falcon]

Here's the latest.

Lucroy is now off the table. Deal now is Kemp for Bryce Harper and Aram. Thoughts?

[bryanbutler]

i take that under normal conditions, but i'm not sure who you drop from your keeper list...

[Fresno Bob]

Here's the latest.

Lucroy is now off the table. Deal now is Kemp for Bryce Harper and Aram. Thoughts?

I like Harper over Kemp straight up, but I like the original deal better since it lets you grab a $1 OF

[Gregg]

This one is fine, but I agree with Fresno and like the first deal much more.

[joncarlos]

Here's the latest.

Lucroy is now off the table. Deal now is Kemp for Bryce Harper and Aram. Thoughts?

Yes. And just drop Aramis.