Help me rate my AL prospects.

[Gregg]

This is a 12 team AL only 5x5 ultra we have 23 man rosters and 17 man reserves. We can keep up to 15 players and 3 minor league prospects (up to 6 prospects if we only keep 12 on our roster).

While helping me this year is important. The bigger picture in our league is having the best keeper potential. Our league is patient and will wait in some cases for years.

Please rate my prospects for greatest over all potential. The number in parenthesis is rhd's current ranking.


Hunter Harvey (49)
Micah Johnson (63)
Mike Foltynewicz (110)
Delino DeShields (116)
Devon Travis (118)
Gary Sanchez (dropped off top 150)
D.J. Davis (not listed)

Thank you.

[joncarlos]

I'm over Delino. I think DJ Davis still has upside, though it's admittedly an extreme longshot. I only like Folty as a lottery ticket closer. Travis is low ceiling but a pretty likely contributor which I have to think has some value in a 12-team AL. Micah is a slightly better version of Deshields. I think Sanchez could be a 2nd division 1B.

Harvey
=====
Travis
Davis
Johnson
=====
Sanchez
Folty
Deshields

[chancellor]

I like JCs list, though I'd move Micah Johnson to the top of tier 2 and move the other two down one slot each.