Mesoraco or Garza?

[Gregg]

NL only 5x5.

Mesoraco is 15B (play out or sign at $5 per yr) Garza is 7B (play out or can sign).

Is this a fair trade straight up?

Which side do you prefer?

Thanks.

[Moonlight J]

Mesoraco....position + the power premium

[joncarlos]

I really like Garza but declining IP for 2 years, and last year's K/9 drop.... coin flip for me. Assuming of course this is a 2-catcher league. 1 catcher league I think I take Garza.

[mgwiz22]

I would prefer Mesaraco. It's a lot easier to replace Garza.

[revo]

Mesoraco and it's not close. Garza's K% has declined for four straight seasons, and Mesoraco led MLB in HRs by a catcher.

[DMT]

Mesoraco

[Gregg]

Thanks fellas. It is a 2 catcher league with 12 teams.

[chancellor]

Mesoraco....position + the power premium

What he said, and I'd play Mesoraco out at 15.