Mixed League Keepers

[onejayhawk]

Pick one of:

SS J.P. Crawford Phi
3B Jake Lamb Ari
RP Héctor Rondón ChC
RP Santiago Casilla SF
SP Robert Stephenson Cin
SP Drew Pomeranz Oak

16 team H2H, semi-dynasty. This is for 2015 and 2016 mostly. There are escalating options through 2018, but the third option year is likely too expensive and the second might be.

J

[joncarlos]

Unless you think you could trade Crawford for a better one down the road, I'd lean towards 1 of the closers. Probably Rondon. Pomeranz would be a good choice too.

[onejayhawk]

Here's the rest of the roster. RP is easier to draft than other things. I have a 5th and a 7th, though they work more like a late 6th and an 8th because of other team's option keepers. About 90 of the top 120 are kept and the rest go fast.

The number is the draft round the option costs. Three required keepers, plus an open 4th.

1B Paul Goldschmidt Ari (4)
2B Robinson Canó Sea (4)
3B Adrián Béltre Tex (4)
SS Danny Santana Min (W)
OF Andrew McCutchen Pit (4)
OF Kole Calhoun LAA (10)
OF Jayson Werth Was (6)
OF Christian Yelich Mia (14)
MI
CI Miguel Sano Min (11)
UTIL

SP Matt Harvey NYM (13)
SP Zack Wheeler NYM (8)
SP Carlos Carrasco Cle (W)
SP José Fernández Mia (12)
RP
RP
RP
P Noah Syndergaard NYM (12)
P
P

The Farm

OF Byron Buxton Min (19)
OF Clint Frazier Cle (24)
SS Raúl Mondesí KC (25)
SP Lucas Giolito Was (20)
SP Carlos Rodon CWS (21)

Side question. I have Syndergaard, Fernandez, Sano and Calhoun in three rounds. One will to be pushed into round 9. How would you order them? Option cost is keeper round minus four.

J