SP flyer - McDonald or Beachy?

[Spec R]

Need some SP depth while Greinke and Morrow are on the DL. Who is the better bet? Beachy or McDonald? Leaning toward Beachy simply b/c he is on the better team.

[Sam]

Need some SP depth while Greinke and Morrow are on the DL. Who is the better bet? Beachy or McDonald? Leaning toward Beachy simply b/c he is on the better team.

While I think McDonald probably has higher upside in the long term, if you're looking for someone just for the intermediate while your guys are on the DL then I think Beachy is your man.

[Spec R]

beachy looking solid today. Through 5ip. 1 er, 4 hits, 1 bb, 6 k's

[Sour Masher]

Another vote for Beachy for the short term, but McDonald for the long term.