HELP - keeper 2023

[swampdragon]

We changed some rules and can keep three players in the drafted round for one year - but must be drafted in round 5 at earliest
12 team yahoo - OBP 5x5 WINS

I am keeping Austin Riley in the 20th round
either Valdez 26 or Montas 19

RANK THESE OTHER TRADE TARGETS - I would keep ONE
Alcantara 9th - owner will definitely trade
Chisholm 26th round - owner will likely trade
Ohtani (Hitter) 10th round - would take a big push to get him, but could do it

thanks

[The Feral Slasher]

We changed some rules and can keep three players in the drafted round for one year - but must be drafted in round 5 at earliest
12 team yahoo - OBP 5x5 WINS

I am keeping Austin Riley in the 20th round
either Valdez 26 or Montas 19

RANK THESE OTHER TRADE TARGETS - I would keep ONE
Alcantara 9th - owner will definitely trade
Chisholm 26th round - owner will likely trade
Ohtani (Hitter) 10th round - would take a big push to get him, but could do it

thanks

With Chisholm being such a late round pick it makes it a tough choice. I think I would get whoever is cheapest to acquire.

[virgonomic]

Alcantara - give me an ace in the 9th round all day long.
Jazz - As hitters, a healthy Jazz and Ohtani are pretty close, and Ohtani is DH-only, so Jazz is a clear #2 16 rounds later.
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
Ohtani

[harmon]

NL MVP and Cy Young winner on the same team sounds pretty good to me. I would go for Sandy all day.

[swampdragon]

different choice for 3rd keeper

Alcantara 9th round

OR

Manoah 15th round

which one for next year?

[The Feral Slasher]

different choice for 3rd keeper

Alcantara 9th round

OR

Manoah 15th round

which one for next year?

If it is for just one year I would go Alcantara.

[virgonomic]

If it is for just one year I would go Alcantara.

Agree, though it's close and you can't go wrong either way.

[Sharky]

Another vote for Alcantara.