NL Trade Offer Need Advise

[pitbull]

NL only 5x5 10 team keeper league.

Offered Taylor Rogers for Kyle Harrison.

He also has Edwin Diaz. I think I could get either but which would you choose? Rogers is $20 and Diaz is $21.

[FBP]

Coin flip, but Diaz has longer track record as a closer.

[Gregg]

Coin flip, but Diaz has longer track record as a closer.

Diaz is three years younger and has the advantage in K's. Given the choice I take Diaz.

[pitbull]

I had to settle on Rogers because the owner sent Diaz to another team. I have Bedard as the other closer also have Floro if he ever gets it together. Bench players I have Mantiply, Dominquez and the other Rogers. This should net me 4-5 points over time.

[FBP]

Rogers is OK. padres play a lot of close games.