Who's the MVP?

[JudeBaldo]

Brees, Rodgers, or Brady?

[revo]

I'd go Rodgers, still pretty easily.

All were phenomenal, so let's get that out of the way. If there was a way to simply divide up the pie, this would be an ideal year to do it. But......Rodgers seemed to create his wins. He simply just found a guy open and nailed him. He had almost no running game. He had a crappy defense, so he needed 30+ points a week. It seemed like NO just piled on all year. If they played to win, Brees would have had 1,000 less yards.

And NE had a great, revolutionary scheme -- athletic Tight Ends. Go figure.

And at least NE & NO had solid runners, if they ever chose to use them. Brees had the unreal weapon of Sproles, which NO used remarkably well. But Rodgers just had his accurate arm and a deep ball.

To me, Rodgers wins in a landslide (not sure if they reveal NFL MVP voting), with Brees #2 on almost all ballots.

[DMT]

Brees overtook Rodgers in the final month IMO but I'd split my vote b/w the two if I had one.

[TS Garp]

Rodgers by a ton.

[DMT]

Rodgers by a ton.

Nonsense

[Long John]

I'm a Packers fan, admittedly. I'd like to see Rodgers win, but I'm much more interested in the Packers repeating this year. Let's put it this way; if Brees wins the MVP and the Packers win the Super Bowl, I won't be upset in the least.

[TS Garp]

Nonsense

The QB ratings aren't close. Putting that aside, as the worth of QB rating is debatable, Brees had more yards and a higher completion %. He had 1 more TD despite 155 more attempts than Rodgers. And he had 8 more interceptions. Rodgers also rushed for 171 more yards and 3 more TD's. And the Packers had a better record. The numbers speak for themselves. Brees had a phenomenal year, but not as phenomenal as the season Rodgers had.

[owned]

The QB ratings aren't close. Putting that aside, as the worth of QB rating is debatable, Brees had more yards and a higher completion %. He had 1 more TD despite 155 more attempts than Rodgers. And he had 8 more interceptions. Rodgers also rushed for 171 more yards and 3 more TD's. And the Packers had a better record. The numbers speak for themselves. Brees had a phenomenal year, but not as phenomenal as the season Rodgers had.

If the numbers speak for themselves, Rodgers isn't even the best QB on the Packers.

[Hammer]

Flynns performance did take a bit of the shine off of Rodgers season but I still think Rodgers efficiency along with the Packers going 15-1 with a statistically bottom 2 or 3 defense gives him the trophy.

[Pauly]

Flynns performance did take a bit of the shine off of Rodgers season but I still think Rodgers efficiency along with the Packers going 15-1 with a statistically bottom 2 or 3 defense gives him the trophy.

Brady's defense is even worse and they are the best team in the AFC (said the Brady owner who won the fantasy championship this year). It's just when you watch Brady run the game, you just know he is the best player in the league.

[griswold]

I think it should go to Rodgers....but it's close....however, I think the NFL will play politically correct and award co-MVP's.

Hey, just my thoughts.

Gris

[joncarlos]

I'm going with Rodgers. I'm not swayed by Flynn's performance in week 17 - the Lions defense is B-A-D.

[jwlincy]

Rodgers and its not very close.

[revo]

I think it should go to Rodgers....but it's close....however, I think the NFL will play politically correct and award co-MVP's.

Hey, just my thoughts.

Gris

The NFL doesn't give out the MVP award. The Associated Press's MVP is the most widely accepted Award.

[umjewman]

Barf, but....Peyton Manning.