Rios, Craig and Kimbrel

[Mithrandir]

5x5..Mixed...14 teams auction league..$300 draft day budget

Rios: $9 in 2014 and $14 in 2015
Craig : $6 in 2014 and $11 in 2015
Kimbrel: $21 in 2014 back in draft in 2015

If you owned Rios and Craig would you trade one of them for Kimbrel? If you owned Kimbrel would you trade him for one of those two. If so, which one Rios or Craig?

I own Rios and Craig. I also have Frieri and Cishek, both for $6. I like to have 3 closers as that virtually guarantees a top 3 finish in saves.

Thanks.

[revo]

I wouldn't consider trading Rios or Craig for Kimbrel at their respective salaries.

[Mithrandir]

I wouldn't consider trading Rios or Craig for Kimbrel at their respective salaries.

Thanks Revo. I do think they are at too good a price to deal, but i am always having doubts about both of them keeping up their stats...i don't know why, other than it's just me being pessimistic.

[chancellor]

I wouldn't consider trading Rios or Craig for Kimbrel at their respective salaries.

Agree completely. Kimbrel is the gold standard for closers now, but in a league your size, I think you can find a serviceable third closer at a much better price.

[Mithrandir]

Agree completely. Kimbrel is the gold standard for closers now, but in a league your size, I think you can find a serviceable third closer at a much better price.

Thanks Chance.

[madducks]

If they were the same price i would do a one for one deal. IMO, Rios and Craig are priced below value while Kimbrel is priced at or near value.

[Mithrandir]

If they were the same price i would do a one for one deal. IMO, Rios and Craig are priced below value while Kimbrel is priced at or near value.

Then trade me Goldschmidt for those two

[madducks]

Then trade me Goldschmidt for those two

I was responding to the first post about the other owner and Kimbrel.