Need to keep 8

[Flyman]

It's a 12-team mixed league, draft no salaries, traditional 5x5, traditional 23 active positions.

I'm looking at 1B Chris Davis, OF Carlos Gonzales, OF Carlos Gomez, SP Madison Bumgarner, and SP Max Scherzer as definites.

To fill my other three keeper slots, I'm looking at:
Andrus
Tulowitzki
Heyward
DJennings
SGray

Outside possibilities that I'm not considering all that much: LMartin, JCastro, EYoung, Kluber.

Which of the five others would you keep? Would you keep any of them over the five guys I consider to be "definites"?

[virgonomic]

Agree with your definites.

I like: Andrus, Tulowitzki, Heyward

[joncarlos]

Definitely Tulo and Heyward. I will never give up on J-Hey.

I think I would keep Andrus too. He's a lot like Jennings and Martin but you can play him at MI. I like Gray too but young pitchers are always scary.

[Hammer]

Tulo, Heyward and Andrus

[Erik]

Tulo, Heyward and Andrus

I'll go with this too. It should be a benefit to have SS and MI locked in beforehand.

[onejayhawk]

I would handcuff Tulo and Andrus unless a solid SS is likely to be available. Heyward is an easy pick for the other slot.

J