which 3B?

[bryanbutler]

i need to replace sizemore, who was a short-term replacement for han-ram. those available in my league that have any AB (sorted by AB):

Eric Chavez
Conor Gillaspie
Joaquin Arias
Juan Uribe
Brendan Harris
Jerry Hairston
Cody Ransom
Jack Hannahan
Nick Punto
Josh Wilson

which should i try to FAAB? 5x5 league, with OBA, XBA, and SB-CS.

[revo]

I'd try out Gillaspie, who could get FT ABs with Beckham out.

[JudeBaldo]

I'd try out Gillaspie, who could get FT ABs with Beckham out.

Second

[bryanbutler]

thanks, guys. good point - bid is in.

[TranaGreg]

I'm in a similar situation ... debating between Gillaspie & Ryan Roberts who is getting some pt in Tampa ... thoughts? I'm leaning Roberts.

[Stephen]

That one is a toss up for me TG. Roberts has shown that he can hit for a little power in the big leagues, but his playing time is anything but guaranteed.

Gillaspie has shown nothing the way of power, but he has hit as many as 14 HR in a season in the minors. He also has a better hitter's park and a more defined role for the immediate future.

I'd go with Gillaspie, but these guys are probably a coin flip difference at best.

[bryanbutler]

gillaspie ended up going for $10 - $4 more than i bid. sigh.