What would you give for Lindor and Stroman?

[Erik]

Someone in my league is offering Lindor and Stroman and is looking for a single stud in return. Lindor and Stroman are both the equivalent of $4. We don't have contracts; to keep a guy, you give them a 50% raise, and you can keep up to 6 for each year.

Would you give any of these guys for the Lindor/Stroman package?

Frazier equivalent of $20
Carlos Gomez equivalent of $12
Puig equivalent of $8

Thanks!

[Andrewski]

I *think* I understand your rules, and my answer is:

YES.

TO ALL.

(assuming that this is not a super shallow league)

[joncarlos]

4,6,9,13.50 (say 14), 21... you could have these guys as cornerstones for 5 years.

I would give any of them individually. I would probably deal Frazier + Gomez. Maybe even Puig + Frazier.

[Mithrandir]

I wouldn't consider any of the 3 you might offer as "studs".

It also depends on how much you value Stroman.

I would definitely deal Puig. Maybe deal Gomez. Probably deal Frazier.

[Erik]

Thanks, guys. We'll see what he thinks. His ideas of value are a little odd sometimes.

[cool hand]

Frazier would be the obvious one to part with, then Gomez, then Puig. I would make any of those deals, although I'm not a big fan of Lindor. Big fan of Stroman, though.

This, precisely.

[Erik]

He changed his mind and decided he doesn't want to move Lindor after all. Oh well.

[Sour Masher]

He changed his mind and decided he doesn't want to move Lindor after all. Oh well.

Would he give Stroman $4 and anything else for Frazier $20? If Lindor is his hang up and you want pitching, that might still be something to consider.