Peavy or Webb?

[Gregg]

High risk, high reward.

Who do you like for this year?

What would you be willing to pay in an auction format keeper league?

[Sour Masher]

I don't think I'll go after either, even in a keeper league, but if the bidding stopped at under $5, I guess you have to take the plunge. I think the odds of them doing much of anything this year are pretty slim.

If I had to pick one to target, I'd probably go for Peavy. His injury is odd enough that we don't have clear data to suggest that he can't come back from it. Webb's injury has a history of ruining a pitcher.