Steve Smith for Ryan Mathews

[billbuckner]

Just got offered Steve Smith (the good one) for Ryan Mathews. I was planning on rejecting this because I like my WRs and am a bit sketchy at RB but I wanted to get some other thoughts and make sure I'm not overvaluing mathews or undervaluing Smith . 12 teams, .5 PPR

Here's my team:

QB: Fitz
WR: S Moss
WR: D Bryant
WR: K Britt
RB: Mendenhall
RB: Mathews
WR/RB: Tate
TE: Finley
K: whatev
DEF: whatev

BN: Eli
BN: M Floyd
BN: Addai
BN: Moreno
BN: P Thomas
BN: Holley (in case Dez can't go monday)

[revo]

it's not a bad offer, but I don't think you can afford to give up Mathews for another WR.

[joncarlos]

I like Knowshawn and I think the Saints will figure out Thomas. I would do this deal... I love Smith and hate Matthews... and figure the rest out later. Maybe you could sell high on Britt for an RB1.