Going to start this thread, but don't blame me if it's not 100% up to date all the time.
1.01 Babe Ruth OF 1921
1.02 Walter Johnson P 1913
1.03 Cy Young P 1892
1.04 Hank Aaron OF/1B 1963
1.05 Ty Cobb OF 1911
1.06 Jimmie Foxx 1B 1932
1.07 Nap Lajoie 2B/1B 1901
1.08 Pete Alexander P 1915
1.09 Christy Mathewson P 1908
1.10 Lou Gehrig 1B 1927
2.01 Carl Yastrzemski OF/1B 1967
2.02 Rogers Hornsby SS/2B 1922
2.03 Mel Ott OF/3B 1929
2.04 Dennis Eckersley P 1990
2.05 Charley Radbourn P 1884
2.06 Rickey Henderson OF 1985
2.07 Rudy York C/1B 1940
2.08 Dwight Evans OF 1987
2.09 Ed Walsh P 1908
2.10 Robin Yount SS/OF 1982
3.01 Billy Hamilton OF 1894
3.02 Stan Musial OF/1B 1948
3.03 Albert Pujols OF/1B 2010
3.04 Heinie Zimmerman 2B/3B 1912
3.05 Cap Anson 3B/1B 1886
3.06 Buck Ewing C/OF/1B 1889
3.07 Tim Keefe P 1888
3.08 Ted Williams OF 1949
3.09 Sandy Koufax P 1965
3.10 Dan Quisenberry P 1983
4.01 Alex Rodriguez SS/3B 2007
4.02 Mariano Rivera P 2011
4.03 George Van Haltren OF 1891
4.04 Joe DiMaggio OF 1948
4.05 Kid Nichols P 1898
4.06 Jim O'Rourke C/OF/1B 1890
4.07 Hugh Duffy OF 1894
4.08 Trevor Hoffman P 1998
4.09 Joe Torre C/3B/1B 1971
4.10 Barry Bonds OF 2001
5.01 Mike Piazza C 1997
5.02 George Davis SS/OF/3B 1897
5.03 Randy Johnson P 2002
5.04 Addie Joss P 1908
5.05 Ugueth Urbina P 1998
5.06 Jason Isringhausen P 2004
5.07 Michael Young SS/2B/3B 2011
5.08 Gaylord Perry P 1972
5.09 Eddie Plank P 1915
5.10 Robb Nen P 2000
6.01 Luis Tiant P 1968
6.02 Honus Wagner SS/OF/3B/1B 1905
6.03 King Kelly C/OF 1886
6.04 Tris Speaker OF 1912
6.05 Willie Mays OF 1955
6.06 Bob Gibson P 1968
6.07 Joe Nathan P 2006
6.08 Arky Vaughan SS 1940
6.09 Dazzy Vance P 1924
6.10 Jose Valverde P 2011
7.01 Derek Jeter SS 2012
7.02 Eddie Collins 2B 1914
7.03 Ed Delahanty OF/1B 1901
7.04 Frankie Frisch 2B/3B 1921
7.05 Frank Robinson OF/1B 1962
7.06 Chase Utley 2B 2006
7.07 Hughie Jennings SS/1B 1895
7.08 Lave Cross C/3B 1902
7.09 Tom Seaver P 1971
7.10 Chuck Klein OF 1930
8.01 Mordecai Brown P 1909
8.02 Arlie Latham 3B 1887
8.03 Rollie Fingers P 1981
8.04 Harry Heilmann OF/1B 1921
8.05 Fergie Jenkins P 1968
8.06 Pedro Martinez P 2000
8.07 Del Ennis OF 1950
8.08 Gus Zernial OF 1951
8.09 Ken Griffey Jr. OF 1997
8.10 Monte Irvin OF 1951
9.01 Carlton Fisk C 1977
9.02 Jonathan Papelbon P 2012
9.03 Ivan Rodriguez C 1999
9.04 Willie Keeler OF 1900
9.05 Al Simmons OF 1930
9.06 Sam Thompson OF 1895
9.07 Mickey Mantle OF/1B 1956
9.08 Joe Morgan 2B 1976
9.09 Reggie Jackson OF 1969
9.10 Bob Elliott OF/3B 1947
10.01 Joe Jackson OF 1911
10.02 Hal Newhouser P 1946
10.03 Sammy Sosa OF 1998
10.04 Phil Niekro P 1969
10.05 Charlie Gehringer 2B 1929
10.06 John Franco P 1988
10.07 Roger Clemens P 1986
10.08 Cecil Upshaw P 1969
10.09 Whitey Ford P 1958
10.10 Greg Maddux P 1995
11.01 Don Drysdale P 1964
11.02 Ross Youngs OF 1924
11.03 Roberto Alomar 2B 2001
11.04 Hippo Vaughn P 1918
11.05 Justin Verlander P 2011
11.06 Johnny Bench C 1970
11.07 Raul Ibanez OF 2006
11.08 Pud Galvin P 1884
11.09 John Clarkson P 1885
11.10 Paul Molitor 2B/3B 1987
12.01 Babe Adams P 1920
12.02 Hank Greenberg OF/1B 1940
12.03 Ernie Banks SS/1B 1958
12.04 Eddie Cicotte P 1917
12.05 Dutch Leonard P 1914
12.06 Jeff Kent 2B 2000
12.07 Guy Hecker P 1884
12.08 Ted Simmons C 1975
12.09 Tip O'Neill OF 1887
12.10 Orval Overall P 1909
13.01 Dick Allen OF/3B/1B 1966
13.02 Dan Uggla 2B 2010
13.03 Joe Cronin SS 1930
13.04 Craig Biggio C/2B/OF 1997
13.05 Jim Palmer P 1975
13.06 Rube Waddell P 1905
13.07 Earl Averill OF 1931
13.08 Tom Henke P 1995
13.09 Frank Thomas 1B 1996
13.10 Tom Daly C/2B 1901
14.01 Steve Carlton P 1972
14.02 Yogi Berra C/OF 1950
14.03 Johnny Evers 2B 1912
14.04 Jim Thome 3B/1B 1996
14.05 Rafael Palmeiro OF/1B 1999
14.06 Darrell Evans 3B/1B 1973
14.07 Bill Terry 1B 1930
14.08 Gary Nolan P 1967
14.09 John Smoltz P 2003
14.10 Joe Quinn 2B 1889
15.01 Bill Nicholson OF 1943
15.02 Rick Aguilera P 1991
15.03 Joe Kelley OF/1B 1895
15.04 Koji Uehara P 2010
15.05 Eddie Yuhas P 1952
15.06 Carl Hubbell P 1933
15.07 Ed Reulbach P 1905
15.08 Chad Qualls P 2009
15.09 George Foster OF 1977
15.10 John Ward P 1880
16.01 Herman Long SS 1889
16.02 Gregg Olson P 1992
16.03 Hal Trosky 1B 1936
16.04 Billy Wagner P 2010
16.05 Don Sutton P 1972
16.06 Chief Bender P 1910
16.07 Denny Lyons 3B 1887
16.08 George Bradley P 1876
16.09 Jim Edmonds OF 2000
16.10 Freddie Lindstrom OF/3B 1930
17.01 Joe Wood P 1912
17.02 Mel Queen P 1967
17.03 Roy Face P 1959
17.04 Cal Ripken Jr. SS/3B 1983
17.05 Chipper Jones OF/3B 1999
17.06 Bill Dahlen SS/3B 1904
17.07 Lefty Grove P 1931
17.08 Sam Leever P 1903
17.09 Chief Zimmer C 1895
17.10 Amos Otis OF 1979
18.01 Duke Farrell C/3B 1891
18.02 Andre Dawson OF 1987
18.03 Manny Ramirez OF 2005
18.04 Lou Brock OF 1974
18.05 Al Kaline OF 1961
18.06 Tony Lazzeri 2B 1929
18.07 Warren Spahn P 1953
18.08 Lefty O'Doul OF 1929
18.09 Silver King P 1888
18.10 Hod Eller P 1920
19.01 Rich Gossage P 1980
19.02 Matt Nokes C 1987
19.03 John Tudor P 1985
19.04 Magglio Ordonez OF 2002
19.05 Mike Napoli C 2011
19.06 Bobby Veach OF 1919
19.07 George Zuverink P 1957
19.08 Dizzy Dean P 1934
19.09 Joey Votto 1B 2010
19.10 Troy Percival P 1996
20.01 Brad Ziegler P 2012
20.02 Luke Appling SS 1936
20.03 Willie Upshaw 1B 1983
20.04 Lance Parrish C 1983
20.05 Steve Olin P 1992
20.06 Cecil Travis SS/3B 1941
20.07 Ron Guidry P 1978
20.08 Doc White P 1906
20.09 Mickey Lolich P 1972
20.10 Larry Corcoran P 1880
21.01 Kent Tekulve P 1979
21.02 Babe Herman OF/1B 1930
21.03 Tim Lincecum P 2011
21.04 Hoyt Wilhelm P 1964
1.01 Babe Ruth OF 1921
1.02 Walter Johnson P 1913
1.03 Cy Young P 1892
1.04 Hank Aaron OF/1B 1963
1.05 Ty Cobb OF 1911
1.06 Jimmie Foxx 1B 1932
1.07 Nap Lajoie 2B/1B 1901
1.08 Pete Alexander P 1915
1.09 Christy Mathewson P 1908
1.10 Lou Gehrig 1B 1927
2.01 Carl Yastrzemski OF/1B 1967
2.02 Rogers Hornsby SS/2B 1922
2.03 Mel Ott OF/3B 1929
2.04 Dennis Eckersley P 1990
2.05 Charley Radbourn P 1884
2.06 Rickey Henderson OF 1985
2.07 Rudy York C/1B 1940
2.08 Dwight Evans OF 1987
2.09 Ed Walsh P 1908
2.10 Robin Yount SS/OF 1982
3.01 Billy Hamilton OF 1894
3.02 Stan Musial OF/1B 1948
3.03 Albert Pujols OF/1B 2010
3.04 Heinie Zimmerman 2B/3B 1912
3.05 Cap Anson 3B/1B 1886
3.06 Buck Ewing C/OF/1B 1889
3.07 Tim Keefe P 1888
3.08 Ted Williams OF 1949
3.09 Sandy Koufax P 1965
3.10 Dan Quisenberry P 1983
4.01 Alex Rodriguez SS/3B 2007
4.02 Mariano Rivera P 2011
4.03 George Van Haltren OF 1891
4.04 Joe DiMaggio OF 1948
4.05 Kid Nichols P 1898
4.06 Jim O'Rourke C/OF/1B 1890
4.07 Hugh Duffy OF 1894
4.08 Trevor Hoffman P 1998
4.09 Joe Torre C/3B/1B 1971
4.10 Barry Bonds OF 2001
5.01 Mike Piazza C 1997
5.02 George Davis SS/OF/3B 1897
5.03 Randy Johnson P 2002
5.04 Addie Joss P 1908
5.05 Ugueth Urbina P 1998
5.06 Jason Isringhausen P 2004
5.07 Michael Young SS/2B/3B 2011
5.08 Gaylord Perry P 1972
5.09 Eddie Plank P 1915
5.10 Robb Nen P 2000
6.01 Luis Tiant P 1968
6.02 Honus Wagner SS/OF/3B/1B 1905
6.03 King Kelly C/OF 1886
6.04 Tris Speaker OF 1912
6.05 Willie Mays OF 1955
6.06 Bob Gibson P 1968
6.07 Joe Nathan P 2006
6.08 Arky Vaughan SS 1940
6.09 Dazzy Vance P 1924
6.10 Jose Valverde P 2011
7.01 Derek Jeter SS 2012
7.02 Eddie Collins 2B 1914
7.03 Ed Delahanty OF/1B 1901
7.04 Frankie Frisch 2B/3B 1921
7.05 Frank Robinson OF/1B 1962
7.06 Chase Utley 2B 2006
7.07 Hughie Jennings SS/1B 1895
7.08 Lave Cross C/3B 1902
7.09 Tom Seaver P 1971
7.10 Chuck Klein OF 1930
8.01 Mordecai Brown P 1909
8.02 Arlie Latham 3B 1887
8.03 Rollie Fingers P 1981
8.04 Harry Heilmann OF/1B 1921
8.05 Fergie Jenkins P 1968
8.06 Pedro Martinez P 2000
8.07 Del Ennis OF 1950
8.08 Gus Zernial OF 1951
8.09 Ken Griffey Jr. OF 1997
8.10 Monte Irvin OF 1951
9.01 Carlton Fisk C 1977
9.02 Jonathan Papelbon P 2012
9.03 Ivan Rodriguez C 1999
9.04 Willie Keeler OF 1900
9.05 Al Simmons OF 1930
9.06 Sam Thompson OF 1895
9.07 Mickey Mantle OF/1B 1956
9.08 Joe Morgan 2B 1976
9.09 Reggie Jackson OF 1969
9.10 Bob Elliott OF/3B 1947
10.01 Joe Jackson OF 1911
10.02 Hal Newhouser P 1946
10.03 Sammy Sosa OF 1998
10.04 Phil Niekro P 1969
10.05 Charlie Gehringer 2B 1929
10.06 John Franco P 1988
10.07 Roger Clemens P 1986
10.08 Cecil Upshaw P 1969
10.09 Whitey Ford P 1958
10.10 Greg Maddux P 1995
11.01 Don Drysdale P 1964
11.02 Ross Youngs OF 1924
11.03 Roberto Alomar 2B 2001
11.04 Hippo Vaughn P 1918
11.05 Justin Verlander P 2011
11.06 Johnny Bench C 1970
11.07 Raul Ibanez OF 2006
11.08 Pud Galvin P 1884
11.09 John Clarkson P 1885
11.10 Paul Molitor 2B/3B 1987
12.01 Babe Adams P 1920
12.02 Hank Greenberg OF/1B 1940
12.03 Ernie Banks SS/1B 1958
12.04 Eddie Cicotte P 1917
12.05 Dutch Leonard P 1914
12.06 Jeff Kent 2B 2000
12.07 Guy Hecker P 1884
12.08 Ted Simmons C 1975
12.09 Tip O'Neill OF 1887
12.10 Orval Overall P 1909
13.01 Dick Allen OF/3B/1B 1966
13.02 Dan Uggla 2B 2010
13.03 Joe Cronin SS 1930
13.04 Craig Biggio C/2B/OF 1997
13.05 Jim Palmer P 1975
13.06 Rube Waddell P 1905
13.07 Earl Averill OF 1931
13.08 Tom Henke P 1995
13.09 Frank Thomas 1B 1996
13.10 Tom Daly C/2B 1901
14.01 Steve Carlton P 1972
14.02 Yogi Berra C/OF 1950
14.03 Johnny Evers 2B 1912
14.04 Jim Thome 3B/1B 1996
14.05 Rafael Palmeiro OF/1B 1999
14.06 Darrell Evans 3B/1B 1973
14.07 Bill Terry 1B 1930
14.08 Gary Nolan P 1967
14.09 John Smoltz P 2003
14.10 Joe Quinn 2B 1889
15.01 Bill Nicholson OF 1943
15.02 Rick Aguilera P 1991
15.03 Joe Kelley OF/1B 1895
15.04 Koji Uehara P 2010
15.05 Eddie Yuhas P 1952
15.06 Carl Hubbell P 1933
15.07 Ed Reulbach P 1905
15.08 Chad Qualls P 2009
15.09 George Foster OF 1977
15.10 John Ward P 1880
16.01 Herman Long SS 1889
16.02 Gregg Olson P 1992
16.03 Hal Trosky 1B 1936
16.04 Billy Wagner P 2010
16.05 Don Sutton P 1972
16.06 Chief Bender P 1910
16.07 Denny Lyons 3B 1887
16.08 George Bradley P 1876
16.09 Jim Edmonds OF 2000
16.10 Freddie Lindstrom OF/3B 1930
17.01 Joe Wood P 1912
17.02 Mel Queen P 1967
17.03 Roy Face P 1959
17.04 Cal Ripken Jr. SS/3B 1983
17.05 Chipper Jones OF/3B 1999
17.06 Bill Dahlen SS/3B 1904
17.07 Lefty Grove P 1931
17.08 Sam Leever P 1903
17.09 Chief Zimmer C 1895
17.10 Amos Otis OF 1979
18.01 Duke Farrell C/3B 1891
18.02 Andre Dawson OF 1987
18.03 Manny Ramirez OF 2005
18.04 Lou Brock OF 1974
18.05 Al Kaline OF 1961
18.06 Tony Lazzeri 2B 1929
18.07 Warren Spahn P 1953
18.08 Lefty O'Doul OF 1929
18.09 Silver King P 1888
18.10 Hod Eller P 1920
19.01 Rich Gossage P 1980
19.02 Matt Nokes C 1987
19.03 John Tudor P 1985
19.04 Magglio Ordonez OF 2002
19.05 Mike Napoli C 2011
19.06 Bobby Veach OF 1919
19.07 George Zuverink P 1957
19.08 Dizzy Dean P 1934
19.09 Joey Votto 1B 2010
19.10 Troy Percival P 1996
20.01 Brad Ziegler P 2012
20.02 Luke Appling SS 1936
20.03 Willie Upshaw 1B 1983
20.04 Lance Parrish C 1983
20.05 Steve Olin P 1992
20.06 Cecil Travis SS/3B 1941
20.07 Ron Guidry P 1978
20.08 Doc White P 1906
20.09 Mickey Lolich P 1972
20.10 Larry Corcoran P 1880
21.01 Kent Tekulve P 1979
21.02 Babe Herman OF/1B 1930
21.03 Tim Lincecum P 2011
21.04 Hoyt Wilhelm P 1964
Comment