Harrison Bader vs Luis Urias

[whalewang]

9 team NL-only keeper league. Both players at $1 and can be kept for up to 5 more years (with salaries escalating over time). Current ADPs have Urias as a significantly better player.

Which player would you prefer for this year and the future?

[madducks]

I actually prefer the more seasoned Bader. At age 27, he seems ready to break out. I think the 24 year old Urias will have more growing pains in 2022-23

[chancellor]

I’d take Urias - his upside is massive. But you can’t go wrong with either at a buck.

[whalewang]

I’d take Urias - his upside is massive. But you can’t go wrong with either at a buck.

I'd be offering my Bader to another owner who is a Cards homer and likes Bader, hence my asking for feedback before I offer. I know Bader well but I don't know Urias very well and Urias's BA scares me.