AL Only trade

[chancellor]

5x5, 10 team OBP/SLG replace BA/HR. I just landed Austin Hays at 10 on a first year deal. I've been offered McClanahan, also at 10, straight up for him. Much as I like McClanahan, I'll be passing on that deal. I picked up Rogers in the same deal as a throw-in, and the player offering me McClanahan also has Robles. Am thinking of countering Hays/Rogers for McClanahan/Fleming. Fleming is at 3; seems like a good prospective keeper to me.

Thoughts?

[Sharky]

Chance, I’m a big McClanahan believer. Personally I would get him if you can. Impact this year may be a big muted, but I’ve watched him pitch. Tremendous presence and poise, throws 98 with movement. Will be an anchor IMO.

[Hornsby]

I'll almost always keep the hitter if all things are equal, and I don't see McClanahan really paying dividends for another year or two. I'd pass unless you can get more than Fleming...