*** VD 15 Commentary Thread ***

[johnnya24]

Hacko____    46.2    46.7    39.1    46.6    178.602    5
DMT______    49.5    45.2    50.8    47.1    192.555    2
Feral Slash    42.9    52.5    46.0    50.4    191.682    3
Heyelander    37.1    38.1    36.6    30.2    142.148    13
JohnnyA24    50.7    41.4    52.3    49.9    194.338    1
Controller J    29.1    51.8    34.5    50.7    166.045    7
Jmaeroff__    45.2    33.7    34.0    36.7    149.606    10
MookieTy_    54.9    29.8    47.4    30.8    162.907    9
Revo_____    38.5    45.4    38.0    41.8    163.590    8
Cavebird__    37.9    37.8    35.6    37.0    148.283    11
Bene Futu    45.3    43.6    51.9    42.0    182.820    4
Frae_____    33.5    43.2    42.7    48.2    167.560    6
Ken______    36.4    37.6    38.2    35.8    147.946    12

CONFIRMED

Either update your SS, or make sure Dan Brouthers BY is 1887 not 1894.

[cavebird]

For all of Bene's griping about his pick, it jumped him almost 10 points in my projections and into 4th place. A close fight for 1-3 between Johnny, DMT, and Controller Jacobs, with Johnny in the lead.

[cavebird]

Since I don't do projections CB I can't be sure if Smoltz or other Braves pitchers would be better for me. When I thought I was getting Tannehill I liked Smoltz but when I lost Tannehill and had to go to Tekulve I wasn't sure so no argh, but he might have been better for me in the end. Now I get whatever ATL pitcher I decide to take in the last round.

It seemed obvious to me with the projections that Smoltz was way better for me, and someone else was significantly better for you. But I didn't trust you to do projections and not steal Smoltz and mess us both up.

[frae]

It seemed obvious to me with the projections that Smoltz was way better for me, and someone else was significantly better for you. But I didn't trust you to do projections and not steal Smoltz and mess us both up.

Thanks I respect that and it was probably for the best. My laziness was making me just go with taking the best ATL pitcher left in the final round when I only need to project Ken's pick

[cavebird]

Thanks I respect that and it was probably for the best. My laziness was making me just go with taking the best ATL pitcher left in the final round when I only need to project Ken's pick

Lol. If I get the other guy I want who could be snaked snaked from me around the turn, I'll deserve it.

[Ken]

Thanks I respect that and it was probably for the best. My laziness was making me just go with taking the best ATL pitcher left in the final round when I only need to project Ken's pick

I wonder, did you ever project who I was going to pick? I know I didn’t

[cavebird]

I wonder, did you ever project who I was going to pick? I know I didn’t

FWIW, I had Giambi right, but Longoria wrong.

[frae]

I wonder, did you ever project who I was going to pick? I know I didn’t

No i mean I will try to guess your very last pick next round. I didn’t bother with this my picks are all locked in except maybe my Atlanta pitcher though I expect that to be pretty locked in too.

[jmaeroff]

Good value with Longoria there, considering his letter & franchise. I was on the verge of taking him in Round 22, but went with Larkin only because I needed an OBP boost.

[johnnya24]

I posted a VD 16 Discussion Thread ... would be good if everyone could express some opinions and preferences.

[Controller Jacobs]

Not sure I can ppost this correctly with my current config - here is what I added for Tiernan

byh
draft KO Tiernmi01_1891 Tiernmi01 Tiernan Mike 1891 542 166 16 73 111 54 69 3 0 614 0.388 1890

hit_comb
Draft tiernmi01 Tiernan Mike 1891 614 16 73 111 53 0.388 6732 106 853 1316 428 0.392 OF SFG T Deadball 1890

[johnnya24]

Not sure I can ppost this correctly with my current config - here is what I added for Tiernan

byh
draft KO Tiernmi01_1891 Tiernmi01 Tiernan Mike 1891 542 166 16 73 111 54 69 3 0 614 0.388 1890

hit_comb
Draft tiernmi01 Tiernan Mike 1891 614 16 73 111 53 0.388 6732 106 853 1316 428 0.392 OF SFG T Deadball 1890

It's already updated in the downloadable Spreadsheet.

You should be able to copy paste this if you want to do it manually, but don't include the "draft" and "KO" parts. That is ... paste from "tiernmi01" onwards and you should be good.

Also: right click > "paste special" > unicode text.

[The Feral Slasher]

For all of Bene's griping about his pick, it jumped him almost 10 points in my projections and into 4th place. A close fight for 1-3 between Johnny, DMT, and Controller Jacobs, with Johnny in the lead.

With my amazing pick Cavebird is going to once again update his projections... ;0

[The Feral Slasher]

With my amazing pick Cavebird is going to once again update his projections... ;0

if only it were enough....

[cavebird]

With my amazing pick Cavebird is going to once again update his projections... ;0

I had a different Cub WC hitter for you; I'll see if it helps you later. I think DMT (I apparently cannot project any of his picks) might benefit more. But I have to get the new spreadsheet first from download as CJ went ahead and broke the whole system, lol.