*** VD 15 Commentary Thread ***

[johnnya24]

As I quickly redo projections, I must be completely missing something for revo; he's gone way down with taking Burks---although maybe this is because my previous projections had him with Robinson. Or Jim Johnson, lol. It would be funny if losing out on Jim Johnson was crucial in this draft.

Before Robinson, I spent a while trying to figure out where you were getting Revo's projected points from. I couldn't. In my final config before he picked, I actually didn't have him taking Burks.

[johnnya24]

I get an error on Johnny's line on the rounds sheet.

3 of 1 letter will cause an error. I'll fix that in a bit. I have 3xB (Biggio, Bradley and Brown)

[DMT]

3 of 1 letter will cause an error. I'll fix that in a bit. I have 3xB (Biggio, Bradley and Brown)

****4

[cavebird]

****4

He forgot Don Baylor.

[johnnya24]

****4

Yeah 4

I like B's

[heyelander]

Yeah 4

I like B B's

and he can not lie.

[frae]

Since I don't do projections CB I can't be sure if Smoltz or other Braves pitchers would be better for me. When I thought I was getting Tannehill I liked Smoltz but when I lost Tannehill and had to go to Tekulve I wasn't sure so no argh, but he might have been better for me in the end. Now I get whatever ATL pitcher I decide to take in the last round.

[revo]

As I quickly redo projections, I must be completely missing something for revo; he's gone way down with taking Burks---although maybe this is because my previous projections had him with Robinson. Or Jim Johnson, lol. It would be funny if losing out on Jim Johnson was crucial in this draft.

I had Jim Johnson in nearly every iteration, but you can't take them all in the last few rounds. I have two replacements for him that have me 0.5 pts better, but as I changed everyone else's projections who had similar players, I've sunk as well. In my current final projection, Jackie would have been +0.5 pts better.

[johnnya24]

Again:

When Ken comes by, we need some confirmation on the Unconfirmed Round 24 standings ... was way off with Feral's standings.

x	Team      	CH	CP	BYH	BYP	Multi	Place
.01	Hacko____	46.2	46.7	39.1	46.6	178.602	5
.02	DMT______	49.5	45.2	51.2	47.1	192.933	2
.03	Feral Slash	42.9	52.5	46.0	50.4	191.682	3
.04	Heyelander	37.1	38.1	36.6	30.2	142.148	13
.05	JohnnyA24	50.7	41.4	52.3	49.9	194.338	1
.06	Controller J	29.1	51.8	34.5	50.7	166.045	7
.07	Jmaeroff__	45.2	33.7	34.0	36.7	149.606	10
.08	MookieTy_	54.9	29.8	47.1	30.8	162.529	9
.09	Revo_____	38.5	45.4	38.0	41.8	163.590	8
.10	Cavebird__	37.9	37.8	35.6	37.0	148.283	11
.11	Bene Futu	45.3	43.6	51.9	42.0	182.820	4
.12	Frae_____	33.5	43.2	42.7	48.2	167.560	6
.13	Ken______	36.4	37.6	38.2	35.8	147.946	12

[johnnya24]

If anyone else has been independently inputting the picks (i.e. not copy pasting from the history thread) ... that would be useful to see also.

[DMT]

Hacko____	46.2	46.7	39.1	46.6	178.602	5
DMT______	49.5	45.2	50.8	47.1	192.555	2
Feral Slash	42.9	52.5	46.0	50.4	191.682	3
Heyelander	37.1	38.1	36.6	30.2	142.148	13
JohnnyA24	50.7	41.4	52.3	49.9	194.338	1
Controller J	29.1	51.8	34.5	50.7	166.045	7
Jmaeroff__	45.2	33.7	34.0	36.7	149.606	10
MookieTy_	54.9	29.8	47.4	30.8	162.907	9
Revo_____	38.5	45.4	38.0	41.8	163.590	8
Cavebird__	37.9	37.8	35.6	37.0	148.283	11
Bene Futu	45.3	43.6	51.9	42.0	182.820	4
Frae_____	33.5	43.2	42.7	48.2	167.560	6
Ken______	36.4	37.6	38.2	35.8	147.946	12

[Bene Futuis]

Um, DMT, you're supposed to give yourself extra points, not the other way 'round.

[DMT]

Looks like something if off for either Mookie or I because our scores are the only ones that differ.

[DMT]

Um, DMT, you're supposed to give yourself extra points, not the other way 'round.

Seriously wtf am I doing?!?!?

[johnnya24]

OK got it - Mookie's Dan Brothers year ... I had as 1894 not 1887.

I'll update the history thread.